Chapter 42 : The Questions She Earned
Olivia's apartment building was old brick and narrow windows, nestled in a Boston neighborhood that valued privacy over charm. I climbed three flights of stairs to reach her door, my footsteps echoing in the empty stairwell.
She opened before I could knock.
"You got my message."
"Hard to ignore 'We need to talk. Tonight. My place.'"
Olivia stepped back to let me in. Her apartment was spare but personal—books stacked on surfaces, case files spread across the coffee table, a half-finished glass of whiskey sitting beside them. The space of someone who worked too much and rested too little.
"Drink?" she asked.
"Sure."
She poured a second glass and handed it to me. The whiskey was good—expensive enough to suggest it wasn't her everyday choice. Special occasion. Or special conversation.
"Sit," she said.
I took the chair across from the couch. Olivia settled into the cushions with her own glass, her movements deliberate. She was in interrogation mode, but this wasn't the aggressive approach she used on suspects. This was the patient version—the technique she employed when she needed someone to tell her everything voluntarily.
"The breach," she began. "The dream. The way you found Nick Lane faster than any conventional method should have allowed. Walter's midnight phone calls that he thinks I don't know about." She reached to the coffee table and picked up a manila folder. "I've been building this file since your first week. Every observation, every inconsistency, every moment when something about you didn't add up."
She opened the folder. Pages covered in her precise handwriting—dates, locations, observations. Months of documentation.
"I've run backgrounds on you through every database I have access to. Your records are clean, but they're also thin. Almost like someone built them deliberately." She flipped to another page. "Your biometrics match someone named Kade Clark who was born in Wisconsin, educated in California, employed in various consulting positions that are just vague enough to explain anything. But whenever I dig deeper, I hit walls."
"Those walls are there for a reason."
"I'm aware. That's not what I'm asking about." Olivia closed the folder and set it aside. "I'm asking about what I saw at Reiden Lake. What I felt in the dream. What happened when you found Nick Lane and told us exactly where he was without any evidence that should have led you there."
She took a sip of her whiskey. Waited.
I'd known this moment was coming. Had been preparing for it since she'd committed to continuing at the lab. Olivia had earned answers—not all of them, but more than I'd given anyone else.
"The system I mentioned to the team," I began slowly, "the adaptive biological mechanism—that's real. But it's more complex than I described."
"I assumed."
"It integrates with external energy sources. Absorbs them. Translates them into capabilities I can use." I rotated my glass, watching the whiskey catch the light. "When I arrived in Boston, I could barely feel it. Like a hum in the back of my head, always present but never useful. Over time, especially after exposure to certain triggers, it's become more active."
"What kind of triggers?"
"Cortexiphan was one. The Cortexiphan trials that Walter ran—your trials—left a signature in people who were exposed. The first time I got close to someone with that signature, my system began adapting to it." I met her eyes. "That's why I can sense dimensional phenomena. Why I found Nick Lane. Why I could track you in the dream."
Olivia's expression didn't change, but I saw her hand tighten slightly on her glass. "The dream wasn't deliberate."
"No. God, no." I leaned forward, needing her to understand this part clearly. "The Cortexiphan resonance connects us in ways I don't fully control. That night—after everything that happened with Lane, after pushing my system too hard—it reached out while I slept. I had no idea it was going to happen until I was already inside your nightmare."
"You saw everything."
"Yes."
"The testing room. The fire. What Walter did to us as children."
"All of it."
Olivia was silent for a long moment. When she spoke again, her voice was carefully controlled. "Did you know who I was before you joined Fringe Division?"
The question hit close to something I couldn't reveal. The meta-knowledge. The transmigration. The fact that I'd watched her story play out on a screen in another life.
"Not the way you're asking," I said. "But I knew you were important."
"Important how?"
"Important to... what I'm supposed to do. What my system is designed for." I took a drink of whiskey, using the moment to choose my next words carefully. "I'm not ready to explain all of it. There are things about my situation that I don't fully understand myself. But I can tell you this: everything I've done since joining Fringe Division has been to help, not harm. The capabilities I have—the ones you saw at the breach—I used them to save your life. I would do it again."
Olivia processed this with the methodical patience she brought to every investigation. I could almost see her sorting information, categorizing it, filing some away and flagging others for further examination.
"That's not everything," she said finally.
"No."
"You're still holding something back. Something big."
"Yes."
"Why?"
The honest answer would break her understanding of reality. Would force her to accept that her entire life was a story I'd watched play out before I'd ever met her. Would raise questions I couldn't answer about the nature of existence and fate and whether any of us truly had free will.
"Because I don't think you'd believe it," I said. "And because even if you did, I'm not sure it would help."
Olivia studied my face. Looking for tells, probably—the microexpressions that liars couldn't fully suppress. I had no idea what she saw. The training the other Kade had given me through our network link helped control my reactions, but Olivia had been reading people her entire career.
"The part about the dream being involuntary," she said slowly. "That's true."
"Yes."
"The part about using your capabilities to help. Also true."
"Yes."
"But you're lying about something else. Or at least not telling the whole truth."
I didn't deny it.
Olivia refilled both our glasses. The gesture was almost casual—two colleagues having drinks after work, discussing a difficult case. Except the case was me, and the difficulty was everything I couldn't say.
"I interrogate people for a living," she said. "I've interviewed terrorists, serial killers, corporate criminals who thought they were smarter than everyone else. I've learned to tell when someone is lying because they're hiding something malicious, versus when they're lying to protect something they believe matters."
She leaned back against the couch cushions, whiskey glass balanced on her knee.
"You're not lying to protect yourself, Kade. You're lying to protect... I don't know what. Something you think I can't handle. Or something you think would change how I see you."
"Maybe both."
"Probably both." She took a drink. "But here's what I've decided: I'm not going to push. Not tonight. Not tomorrow. You saved my life at that lake. You walked into dimensional energy that should have killed you, and you pulled me out. Whatever you're hiding, that earned you time."
"How much time?"
"Until I decide otherwise." Olivia's eyes were steady on mine. "You owe me the truth, eventually. All of it. And when you're ready to give it, I'll listen. But until then, we keep working. We keep helping people. And you keep proving that whatever you are, you're on our side."
It wasn't trust. It wasn't absolution. It was something more practical—an agreement to move forward despite uncertainty, based on demonstrated actions rather than complete transparency.
I could work with that.
"Thank you," I said.
"Don't thank me yet." Olivia set down her glass and picked up the manila folder again. "I'm not closing this file. I'm just reorganizing it."
"Into what?"
She opened to a fresh page and began writing. "Questions I believe you've answered. Questions I suspect you're still hiding answers to. And questions I'm sure you're lying about." She looked up. "When you're ready to move things from column three to column one, let me know."
I finished my whiskey and stood. The conversation had gone better than I'd feared—worse than I'd hoped. Olivia knew more now, but she also knew that she didn't know enough. The partial truth had bought me time, but it had also shown her exactly how much I was still concealing.
At the door, I paused. "The dream. The nightmare about Jacksonville. I need you to know—experiencing that was the worst night of my life. I'm sorry I saw something that private. And I'm sorry I couldn't stop it from happening."
Olivia was quiet for a moment. Then: "The worst night of my life was the original. Reliving it in a dream wasn't pleasant, but it wasn't the same." She met my eyes. "You didn't violate anything I hadn't already survived. That matters."
I nodded once and left.
The walk back to my hotel took me through cold January streets, past buildings that looked ordinary but might contain dimensional anomalies, past people who had no idea that the barrier between universes was thin enough to touch if you knew how.
I felt lighter for what I'd told Olivia. Heavier for what I hadn't.
Behind me, in an apartment I couldn't see anymore, Olivia Dunham opened her laptop and began a new file. Not evidence this time. Not documentation of suspicious behavior.
Questions.
Organized by what she believed, what she suspected, and what she was sure I was lying about.
The truth would come out eventually. All truths did. But for now, I had bought myself time—time to figure out how to explain the unexplainable, time to prove through actions what I couldn't prove through words.
Time to become someone worthy of the trust I was asking her to give.
Support the Story on Patreon
If you are enjoying the series and would like to read ahead, I offer an early access schedule on Patreon. I upload 7 new chapters every 10 days.
Tiers are available that provide a 7, 14, or 21-chapter head start over the public release. Your support helps me maintain this consistent update pace.
Patreon.com/TransmigratingwithWishes
extra chapters are live on unwrittenrealm.com
also the full story is available in Arabic, Spanish, Hindi, Korean and 10 more. just pick your language.