Emily Prentiss walked into the BAU bullpen at 8:47 AM on a Monday.
I watched her from my desk—confident stride, professional armor in the form of a dark suit that said competent without screaming ambitious. She carried herself like someone who'd walked into hostile rooms before and walked out having won something.
The bullpen's temperature dropped three degrees.
Conversations didn't stop—that would be too obvious—but they contracted. Morgan's laughter at something Reid had said died mid-syllable. JJ's typing slowed. Garcia, who'd emerged from her lair with a fresh batch of cookies, froze in the doorway like a rabbit spotting a hawk.
Emily noticed all of it. Her eyes swept the room with the particular attention of someone cataloguing exits, threats, and potential allies.
"I know I wasn't requested," she said to the room at large. "I'm here anyway."
Hotch emerged from his office.
"Agent Prentiss. Welcome to the BAU." His handshake was professional—neither warm nor cold. "Let me introduce you to the team."
The introductions proceeded with excruciating awkwardness. Morgan's grip was firm but brief, his eyes flat. Reid shook her hand while reciting statistics about State Department counterterrorism operations that were probably meant to establish intellectual territory. JJ was polite in the way of someone reserving judgment.
Gideon didn't appear at all. His office door stayed closed—had stayed closed more often than not in recent weeks.
Garcia recovered first, stepping forward with her particular brand of aggressive warmth.
"Hi! I'm Penelope Garcia, technical analyst and emotional support human. Welcome! Don't let the suspicious stares scare you—they do that with everyone new. It took them weeks to warm up to Ethan, and he's basically harmless."
She gestured toward me. Emily's eyes found mine.
I stood, crossed the bullpen, extended my hand.
"Ethan Mercer. Welcome to the team."
Her grip was firm, her gaze direct. The moment our palms touched, my system activated.
[PROFILE INITIATED: EMILY PRENTISS]
[WARNING: INCOMPLETE DATA]
[COUNTER-SURVEILLANCE TRAINING DETECTED]
[FOCUS: -4]
The analysis came back fragmented. Most people were open books—tells and patterns readable within seconds. Emily's surface was controlled, her micro-expressions deliberately managed.
Someone had trained her to hide.
Interesting.
"The newest before me," she said. "How long have you been here?"
"About a year. Long enough to know the coffee is terrible and the cases are worse."
"Worse how?"
"We hunt serial killers. The coffee just tastes bad."
Something flickered at the corner of her mouth—almost a smile.
"I've been briefed on the coffee."
JJ appeared in the conference room doorway.
"New case. Phoenix field office requesting assistance."
The briefing proceeded with the familiar rhythm of horror rendered clinical. Serial killer in Arizona. Four victims in three weeks. Bodies posed in elaborate configurations—specific positions, specific settings, props arranged like stage dressing.
"He's recreating something," Emily said.
Everyone turned.
She studied the crime scene photos with an intensity that suggested she was seeing patterns the rest of us had missed.
"The positioning, the props, the attention to lighting. He's not just displaying them—he's recreating specific images." She pointed to the third victim. "This one. The angle of her arm, the way the fabric drapes. It's Vermeer. 'Girl with a Pearl Earring.'"
Reid leaned forward.
"The first victim—the placement of her hands..."
"Botticelli's 'Birth of Venus,'" Emily finished. "I'd need to see the others, but I think they're all from the same collection. A specific exhibit, maybe."
Garcia's fingers flew across her keyboard.
"Checking major exhibits featuring these paintings... Got one. National Gallery of Art, DC, 1987. 'Masters of Light and Shadow.' All four paintings were included."
"Cross-reference attendee records with criminal backgrounds," Hotch ordered.
"From 1987? That's creative digging territory, but I'm on it."
The briefing continued, but the dynamic had shifted. Emily had proven something in the first ten minutes—a pattern that had eluded Phoenix PD for three weeks, identified in thirty seconds.
Morgan's posture remained hostile, but his attention had sharpened.
On the jet, I took the seat across from Emily.
She looked up from her file, expression guarded.
"The cold shoulder treatment," I said. "Ignore it. They're protective, not cruel."
"I'm aware. I've been warned about the BAU's... close-knit culture."
"Warned by whom?"
"People with opinions." She studied me. "You're the newest before me. Why aren't you suspicious?"
"I prefer to judge people by their work. And your work in the briefing was solid."
"It was showing off."
"It was being good at your job. That's not the same thing."
Emily was quiet for a moment.
"You're different from the others."
"I wasn't recruited through traditional channels either. I know what it feels like to be an outsider."
"How did you handle it?"
"Did good work. Eventually, results spoke louder than suspicions."
She nodded slowly.
"Practical advice."
The flight attendant came through with drinks. Emily ordered black coffee—same as me. When it arrived, she noticed.
"Simple tastes or hiding something?"
"Both," I admitted. "You?"
"Same."
Something shifted between us—not friendship, but the recognition of kindred spirits. Two people with secrets in a room full of profilers.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes .
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!