Chapter 3: THE NEW CAPTAIN
2:00 PM. The bullpen buzzed with nervous energy.
Terry had stopped doing bicep curls. Amy kept straightening her already-perfect desk. Even Hitchcock and Scully seemed marginally more alert, which mostly meant they were conscious and vertical.
The new captain was coming.
Jake slouched at his desk, radiating defiance. "This is going to be terrible. I can feel it. This guy's going to ruin everything good about this place."
"You don't even know him yet," Amy said.
"I know his type. Strict. By-the-book. Probably irons his socks." Jake spun a pen between his fingers. "McGintley was a disaster, but at least he let us have fun."
"Raymond Holt walks through that door in approximately six minutes, Host. You've seen this scene. You know what happens. The question is: can you watch it unfold without giving yourself away?"
Good question.
I'd watched the pilot episode of Brooklyn Nine-Nine probably a dozen times. Holt's entrance was iconic—the deadpan delivery, the perfectly tailored suit, the immediate tension with Jake. I'd laughed at it, quoted it, rewatched it during particularly bad weeks at my old job.
Now I was about to live it.
The elevator dinged.
Gina didn't look up from her phone. "The new captain's here. This is going to be hilarious."
Footsteps. Measured. Deliberate.
Captain Raymond Holt walked into the Nine-Nine.
He looked exactly like Andre Braugher had on screen—same authoritative posture, same impassive expression, same aura of competence. The suit was impeccable. The badge gleamed. His eyes swept the bullpen, cataloging everything in a single pass.
"Hello. I am your new commanding officer, Captain Raymond Holt."
The delivery was perfect. Flat. Emotionless. Utterly deadpan.
"And here we go. Try not to mouth along, Host. It's suspicious."
My lips pressed together. The urge to recite the next line was almost overwhelming.
"I am a strong, powerful woman—" Gina started.
"Quiet," Holt said.
She shrugged and returned to her phone. On script. Everything on script.
Holt surveyed his new command. His gaze passed over me briefly—new face, nothing notable—before landing on Jake.
"Detective Peralta. I've read your file. Impressive arrest record." A pause that lasted exactly long enough to be uncomfortable. "I will not tolerate insubordination."
"That's—" Jake started.
"I was not finished. I expect professionalism, punctuality, and performance. If you cannot provide these things, we will have problems." Another pause. "You may speak now."
Jake's mouth opened. Closed. Opened again.
"Cool cool cool cool cool. Great speech. Really inspiring stuff. I feel very motivated."
The sarcasm was thick enough to spread on toast. Holt's expression didn't flicker.
"Good. Team meeting in thirty minutes. I will be conducting individual evaluations throughout the afternoon." He turned toward the captain's office. "Dismissed."
The bullpen exhaled.
"Oh, we're doomed," Jake muttered. "We are so doomed."
Amy was already taking notes. "I thought he seemed very professional. I appreciate clear expectations."
"Of course you do."
Rosa hadn't moved from her desk, but her posture radiated hostility like heat from an oven. Charles was hovering near the break room, clutching what appeared to be artisanal butter. Terry looked resigned.
And I sat at my desk, watching a TV show come to life, trying not to scream.
The individual evaluations were alphabetical, which meant I had time to prepare.
Amy came back from hers looking triumphant. "He said my binder system was 'acceptable.' That's practically a compliment."
Charles emerged confused. "He didn't want my butter. Who doesn't want Normandy butter?"
Jake's evaluation lasted twice as long as anyone else's. He returned looking like a man who'd just had his worldview gently but firmly dismantled.
"He... made some points," Jake said slowly. "Valid points. About my arrest record versus my conviction rate. I'm processing."
Then it was my turn.
"Showtime, Host. Captain Holt is observant, intelligent, and excellent at reading people. Don't overthink it. Don't underthink it. Just... be a competent detective who happens to be new."
Helpful.
I knocked on the office door.
"Enter."
Holt sat behind his desk, posture perfect, hands folded. The office was already changing—McGintley's personal items gone, replaced with precisely aligned picture frames and a single potted plant.
"Detective Cole. Please sit."
I sat.
The Social Perception Meter activated automatically—Tier One, still basic, but enough to give me a read.
[RAYMOND HOLT] [Standing: 0 (Neutral)] [Flag: EVALUATING]
Zero. Completely blank. He hadn't formed an opinion yet, positive or negative. The "evaluating" flag meant he was actively assessing everything I did and said.
"He's a blank slate, Host. That's good news. It also means every word counts."
"Detective Cole. Transferred from Queens. Three years on the force. Adequate performance reviews." Holt studied me. "Tell me about yourself."
Standard interview question. Trap embedded.
"I'm a detective who prefers cases to paperwork," I said. "I solve crimes. I try to do it efficiently. I don't have strong opinions about departmental politics."
"A diplomatic answer." Holt's expression remained unreadable. "Your file mentions strong observational skills."
"I pay attention."
"Demonstrate."
"He's testing you. Classic Holt move. Don't show off. Don't undersell. Find the middle."
I looked around the office. The picture frames—two of them, angled slightly. A dog, maybe? Hard to tell from here. The plant was healthy, well-maintained. The desk had nothing personal except a single pen holder with exactly four pens, all black.
"You're meticulous. The pen holder has four pens because you calculated the probability of needing a backup, and then a backup's backup, and then added one more for emergencies. You don't trust chaos, but you know it exists." I paused. "The picture frames are turned slightly away from visitors. Whatever's in them is personal, and you don't share personal details with people who haven't earned the right."
Silence.
Holt's face betrayed nothing. But his posture shifted microscopically—shoulders back, chin lifted. Interest.
"Careful, Host. You're showing too much."
"Good instincts," I added quickly. "Lucky observation."
"Hmm." Holt made a note. "Adequate. You may return to your desk."
[RAYMOND HOLT] [Standing: 0 → +5 (Mild Interest)] [+5 EXP for SPM use]
Not much, but not nothing.
I stood, nodded professionally, and walked out.
[99th Precinct — 4:30 PM]
The team meeting happened exactly as I remembered from the show.
Holt announced new protocols. Jake objected with theatrical hand gestures. Amy took enthusiastic notes. Rosa said nothing but communicated entire novels through eye contact. Charles tried to interject about butter and was politely ignored.
Hitchcock fell asleep four minutes in. Scully joined him by minute six.
I sat in the back, letting it wash over me.
These were real people now. Jake's jokes weren't written by a team of comedy professionals—they were just Jake being Jake. Amy's need to impress wasn't a character trait on a Wikipedia page—it was twenty-eight years of proving herself in male-dominated spaces. Rosa's silence wasn't stoic acting—it was a woman who'd learned early that words gave people weapons against you.
And Holt. Captain Raymond Holt, standing at the front of the room, establishing authority over a precinct that didn't want to change.
I knew he'd win them over. I knew Jake would eventually consider him a father figure. I knew the Halloween Heists and the squad dinners and the moments of genuine connection that were coming.
But they didn't know any of that.
"You're doing the spiral thing again, Host. Come back to earth."
The meeting ended. People dispersed. Jake and Amy continued arguing about proper case documentation procedures. Terry headed for the gym. Gina left without explanation.
I made my way toward the parking lot.
Terry caught me at the elevator.
"Hey, Cole. Quick thing." He pressed a key into my hand. "This is for the supply closet. Don't ask why you might need it. You just might."
"Thanks, Terry."
"Also, you're parked next to the dumpster. New guy spot. Sorry."
"I noticed."
The parking space was, in fact, directly adjacent to a dumpster that smelled like old Chinese food and broken dreams. My car—Marcus Cole's car, a ten-year-old sedan with questionable brakes—sat there like a punishment.
I didn't mind.
Parking spots were fixable problems. The existential crisis of being dead and reborn in a television sitcom? Slightly less fixable.
[Marcus's Apartment — 7:45 PM]
The studio was quiet.
I sat on the edge of the bed—my bed now, apparently—and tried to process the day. New body. New job. New coworkers who didn't know they'd been fictional characters twelve hours ago.
The System had been relatively quiet since leaving the precinct. Now it stirred.
"Not bad for day one, Host. You solved a case. You met the squad. You didn't blow your cover with Holt, though that observation about the pens was a close call."
"Was it wrong?"
"Dead accurate. That's the problem. You're not supposed to be able to read him that well after thirty seconds."
My head ached. The mental stamina bar was hovering around ninety percent—better than after the bodega, but still lower than full.
[CURRENT STATUS] [Level: 1] [EXP: 55/100] [Mental Stamina: 90/100]
Forty-five more points to Level 2.
"What happens when I level up?"
"New abilities unlock. Old ones get stronger. You become better at the thing you're now required to be: a detective."
"Required?"
"You think this is random, Host? You're here for a reason. I don't know what it is yet. But there's a story unfolding, and you're part of it. My job is to make sure you're good enough to survive whatever's coming."
Comforting.
I lay back on the bed. The popcorn ceiling stared down at me. Tomorrow there would be more cases. More interactions with people I'd watched on a screen for years. More chances to slip up, to say the wrong thing, to reveal that I knew exactly how Jake's romance with Amy would develop or what Holt's weaknesses were or that Gina would eventually leave the precinct.
"Stop thinking about tomorrow. Tomorrow doesn't exist yet. Today, you survived. Take the win."
The System was right.
I'd survived.
The apartment's radiator clanked. Outside, Brooklyn rumbled with traffic and sirens and the distant bark of someone's dog. Real sounds. Real city. Real life, even if it had been someone else's fiction.
My phone buzzed.
Unknown number.
"Detective Cole, this is Captain Holt. I reviewed your case file from this morning. The bodega insurance fraud. Your observational notes were thorough." A pause. "I have assigned you as Detective Peralta's regular partner. You will report to me directly on any cases involving property crime. That is all."
The line went dead.
I stared at the phone.
"Look at that. Day one and you've already been noticed. Good news and bad news, Host. Good news: Holt thinks you're competent. Bad news: Holt is now watching you."
Captain Raymond Holt. Watching me.
The man who'd eventually figure out every secret the Nine-Nine ever tried to keep.
I pulled the blanket over my head and wondered if it was too late to get reassigned to Staten Island.
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!