Chapter 5: SHAW'S BAR RULES
Shaw's Bar smelled like spilled beer and old wood and decades of NYPD officers drowning their paperwork sorrows.
I arrived at 8:02—Jake's recommended Rosa-appropriate window—and found the squad already claiming their usual booth. Jake had commandeered one end, gesturing wildly about something. Amy sat beside him, simultaneously listening and organizing the table's scattered coasters into neat stacks. Charles occupied the middle, cradling a drink that appeared to contain several questionable ingredients.
Rosa sat at the far end.
The booth had a spring poking through the cushion on the right side—I could see it from here, a small coil of metal jutting up like a tiny torture device. Rosa was sitting on the left.
And she'd left the spot next to her empty.
"The good seat, Host. She saved you the good seat. In Rosa Diaz terms, this is practically a marriage proposal."
I slid in beside her. "Thanks."
"For what?" She didn't look up from her beer.
"Nothing."
Her lip twitched. Not quite a smile. But not nothing.
[ROSA DIAZ] [Standing: +10 → +12 (Seat Saved)]
Three drinks in, Jake proposed disaster.
"Okay, okay, okay." He set down his beer with the gravity of a man about to declare war. "New guy. Cole. Marcus. Whatever I'm calling you."
"Marcus is fine."
"Marcus." Jake pointed at me with finger-gun intensity. "I challenge you. Next week. Case count. Whoever solves fewer cases buys drinks for a month. A whole month, Marcus. Do you understand the stakes?"
"Ah. A wager. The System enjoys wagers, Host. Let me pull up the mission parameters."
[MISSION AVAILABLE: Win Bet vs Jake Peralta] [Objective: Solve more cases than Jake in one week] [Reward: 75 EXP, $200] [Difficulty: Medium]
The notification floated in my peripheral vision, waiting for acknowledgment.
I could take this mission. My abilities gave me an edge—not a massive one, but enough to probably beat Jake on pure case-closing numbers. Anomaly Detection and Lie Detection meant faster solves, cleaner evidence, shorter interrogations.
But Jake was watching me with competitive hope in his eyes. This wasn't about money or drinks. This was about establishing our dynamic. Testing whether I'd be a rival or a friend.
I'd seen enough episodes to know: Jake needed to win sometimes. His confidence wasn't inexhaustible. And right now, in the early days with Holt, with everything changing, he needed a win more than I needed 75 experience points.
"Host. You're considering throwing this bet. I can feel it. That would be strategically suboptimal."
I ignored the System.
"You're on, Peralta." I extended my hand. "One week. Loser buys."
Jake's grip was enthusiastic. "Oh, you're going to regret this. I'm Jake Peralta. I close cases like other people close doors. Which is frequently and with moderate force."
"That... doesn't make as much sense as you think it does."
"It doesn't need to make sense. It needs to sound cool." He released my hand and turned to Amy. "Santiago! You're witnessing this. Official bet. Official stakes. Official Jake Peralta victory incoming."
Amy made a note on her phone. "Documented. Date, time, terms, witnesses."
"That's my girl."
"We're not dating."
"Yet."
"Host. Seriously. You're planning to lose on purpose. This is objectively foolish behavior. The System rewards performance, not deliberate failure."
I excused myself to the bathroom.
The men's room at Shaw's was tiny, poorly lit, and smelled like industrial cleaner failing to mask decades of bad decisions. Perfect for a private conversation with the voice in my head.
"I need friends more than I need experience points," I said to the mirror.
"Friends don't level you up, Host. Friends don't unlock abilities. Friends won't save you when something bigger than a bodega robbery comes along."
"You don't know that."
"I know that Level 2 is nothing. I know that your abilities are barely functional. I know that you're in a world where things can go very wrong very fast, and you're choosing to handicap yourself for social capital."
"Social capital matters."
"So does not dying."
I splashed water on my face. The fluorescent light made my reflection look exhausted. Marcus Cole's face, still not quite mine, staring back with eyes I was slowly getting used to.
"I'm going to lose the bet," I said. "On purpose. Deal with it."
Silence from the System.
Then: "Fine. Your funeral. Possibly literally."
I dried my hands and headed back to the booth.
Jake was mid-story when I returned—something about a perp who'd tried to escape by climbing into a trash compactor, with predictable results. Charles was laughing so hard he'd spit out his drink. Amy was pretending to be appalled while clearly fighting a smile.
Rosa caught my eye as I sat down.
"You okay? You look like you just lost an argument."
"Something like that."
She didn't push. That was one of the things I was learning to appreciate about Rosa—she asked exactly as many questions as she wanted answers to, and no more.
[ROSA DIAZ] [Flag: OBSERVANT — She noticed something was off]
"Careful, Host. The scary one is watching."
I knew.
The next hour was the most normal I'd felt since waking up in Marcus Cole's body.
Jake told stories. Amy corrected his exaggerations. Charles provided unnecessary food commentary on everyone's drink choices. Rosa drank steadily and occasionally delivered devastating one-liners that made Jake wheeze with laughter.
Gina showed up briefly, pronounced the booth "acceptable," took a selfie that somehow made the bar's terrible lighting look artistic, and left without explanation.
I sat in the good seat, nursing my beer, and let the conversation wash over me.
These people had been fictional characters a week ago. Now they were buying each other drinks and arguing about the proper way to pronounce "caramel" and texting Terry pictures of the scoreboard Charles was apparently planning to create for the bet.
Real people. Real friendships. Real stakes.
"Marcus." Amy's voice cut through my thoughts. "I have questions."
"Here we go. The Santiago Interrogation. Be ready."
"Shoot."
She pulled out her phone—of course she had notes prepared. "First: Queens precinct transfer. What was your solve rate?"
"Respectable."
"Specifics?"
"I don't remember exact numbers."
Her eyes narrowed slightly. "Organization methods. Filing system. Color coding preferences?"
"Alphabetical. Standard manila folders. No color coding."
"Interesting." She made a note. "Coffee recipe."
"Trade secret."
"That's not an answer."
"It's the only answer you're getting."
Jake laughed. "Give it up, Santiago. The man's a vault. I've been trying to crack the coffee thing all week."
Amy wasn't satisfied—I could see it in the way she held her phone, ready to pursue follow-up questions—but Charles distracted her with an unsolicited lecture on the history of Colombian versus Ethiopian beans, and the moment passed.
[AMY SANTIAGO] [Standing: +28 → +30 (Information Exchange)] [Flag: CURIOUS — Will probably ask more questions later]
"She's taking notes on you, Host. Amy Santiago doesn't take notes on people she doesn't find interesting. Could be good. Could be problematic."
Both, probably.
[Shaw's Bar — 11:47 PM]
The crowd thinned. Jake and Amy argued about whether to split an Uber or take separate cabs. Charles had already left, muttering about an early cheese delivery.
Rosa stood, gathering her jacket. "I'm out."
"Motorcycle?" I asked.
"Always."
She paused at the edge of the booth, looking down at me with an expression I couldn't quite read. Her SPM showed +12 (Acknowledged) but there was something else there—curiosity, maybe, or assessment.
"You're weird," she said finally.
"Thanks?"
"Wasn't a compliment." She pulled on her helmet. "See you Monday."
She walked out without waiting for a response. Through the window, I watched her mount a black Yamaha and disappear into Brooklyn's late-night traffic.
"Rosa Diaz thinks you're weird. In her vocabulary, that's practically flirtatious."
"That's not how flirting works."
"Not for normal people. For Rosa? Who knows."
Jake appeared at my elbow, considerably drunker than he'd been an hour ago. "Cole! Marcus! My new nemesis!"
"I thought we were partners."
"Partners can be nemeses. It's called complexity." He draped an arm over my shoulder. "You're going down next week, buddy. Going down hard. I'm going to solve so many cases you'll need a loan to cover the bar tab."
"Looking forward to it."
"You should be scared."
"I'm terrified."
"Good." He released me, swaying slightly. "Amy's calling an Uber. You need a ride?"
"I'll walk. Clear my head."
"Suit yourself. But don't think too hard about your inevitable defeat. It's not healthy."
He stumbled toward Amy, who was already organizing their departure with military precision. Within minutes, they were gone, leaving me alone in a half-empty bar with a nearly finished beer and a lot to think about.
[Brooklyn Streets — 12:15 AM]
The walk home took twenty minutes.
Brooklyn at midnight was quieter than I expected—residential streets giving way to closed storefronts, the occasional bodega still lit up, a few dog walkers finishing late rounds. The September air was cool without being cold, and for the first time in a week, I let myself just... exist.
Not Detective Cole. Not the System's Host. Just a guy walking home from drinks with coworkers.
I'd done this before. In my old life. Different city, different people, different everything—but the feeling was the same. That post-bar contentment, slightly buzzed, processing the evening's conversations.
The difference was, I couldn't remember my old coworkers' faces anymore.
"Getting comfortable, Host?"
"Is that a problem?"
"Comfort breeds complacency. Complacency breeds mistakes. You're still Level 2 in a world that doesn't care about your social calendar."
"I know."
"Do you? Because you're about to throw a bet for friendship points, which suggests maybe you don't fully grasp the stakes here."
"The stakes are my choice."
Silence. Then, grudgingly: "Fair enough. Your life, your decisions. Just don't come crying to me when—"
"When what?"
"Nothing. Forget it. Get some sleep, Host. You've got a bet to lose next week."
I made it home. Climbed the stairs to my tiny apartment. Collapsed on the bed that was slowly starting to feel like mine.
Tomorrow was Saturday. Day off. I could sleep in, eat something that wasn't from a bodega, maybe figure out if Marcus Cole had any hobbies.
But right now, lying in the dark, listening to Brooklyn breathe outside my window, I realized something.
I hadn't thought about my old life in hours.
Not the accident. Not the before. Not anything except Shaw's Bar and Jake's bet and Rosa's cryptic compliment-that-wasn't-a-compliment.
This was my life now.
"Yes, Host. It is. The question is: what are you going to do with it?"
I didn't have an answer yet.
But I was starting to think I might find one.
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!