Chapter 139: The Weight of a Request
The door to the headmaster's office swung open, and every head turned.
Elian Throne walked in as if he were entering the common room after a long day—relaxed, unhurried, utterly unconcerned by the assembled power of the Ministry. His robes bore no signs of his recent journey; the Levitation Cloak was folded neatly under his arm, and his expression was one of mild curiosity, as if he'd stumbled upon an unexpected gathering.
Harry felt a rush of relief so intense his knees nearly buckled. Elian. Finally.
But something was different. Harry couldn't put his finger on it—Elian looked the same, moved the same—but there was a weight to his presence now, a gravity that hadn't been there before. It was as if he'd left a boy and returned a man.
Umbridge's face contorted with fury at this new intrusion. "Thorne! How dare you enter without permission? This is a Ministry investigation!"
Elian glanced at her as one might glance at an annoying insect. "The door was open." He walked past her without waiting for a response, past the glowering Aurors, past Fudge's confused stare, and settled himself onto a vacant sofa as if he owned it. He reached for a small cake from the tray on Dumbledore's desk and took a bite.
"Lin Xiao—" Fudge began, consulting a mental list of names. "You're the Muggle-born. The one who—"
"The one who killed five Death Eaters in Hogsmeade, yes." Elian's voice was casual, almost bored. "Hello again, Minister. You're looking well. Stress agrees with you."
Fudge's mouth opened and closed. He picked up the parchment from the desk, scanning it frantically. "You're not on this list. You're not part of this… this army?"
Elian tilted his head. "Army?"
"Dumbledore's Army!" Fudge thrust the parchment toward him, stabbing a finger at the title. "Your beloved headmaster has been raising a private military force! Using students! Against the Ministry!"
Elian took the parchment, examined it for a moment, then handed it back. "My name's not on it."
"I can see that! But you must have known—"
"Known what?" Elian poured himself a cup of tea from the pot on Dumbledore's desk, adding sugar with careful precision. "That some students wanted to practice defensive magic because the Defence professor is a pink toad who teaches theory from a textbook? Shocking. Truly shocking."
Umbridge made a sound like a teakettle about to explode. "You insolent—!"
"Professor Umbridge." Dumbledore's voice cut through her sputtering like a warm knife through butter. "Mr. Thorne is my guest. As, technically, are you. Let us maintain some semblance of civility."
Someone in the room—Harry thought it might have been Kingsley—suppressed a cough that sounded suspiciously like a laugh.
Fudge, red-faced and flustered, turned back to Dumbledore. "This changes nothing! You've admitted to organizing this illegal group! You've admitted to plotting against the Ministry!"
"Plotting?" Dumbledore's eyebrows rose. "My dear Cornelius, I admitted to nothing of the sort. I merely observed that if you wish to believe I organized a group of students to learn defensive spells and gave it a rather foolish name, I would not contradict you. There is a difference between confession and… accommodation."
Fudge's face cycled through several shades of purple. Umbridge looked as if she might actually combust.
Elian sipped his tea, watching the proceedings with the detached interest of someone observing a particularly entertaining play.
"You—you can't—" Fudge spluttered.
"I believe I just did." Dumbledore rose from his chair, and suddenly the room seemed to shrink. His presence, always formidable, filled every corner. "Cornelius, you came here tonight expecting to destroy me. You brought Aurors, a witness, and the full weight of the Ministry's authority. And what do you have? A girl whose testimony has evaporated. A boy whose family's loyalty is suspect. And a piece of parchment with a silly name written on it."
He walked around his desk, approaching Fudge with slow, measured steps. "You have no evidence of an army. No evidence of training for insurrection. No evidence of anything except what you want to believe. And now, you have a choice."
Fudge backed up a step. "A choice?"
"You can pursue this. You can arrest me, drag me to the Ministry, stage a show trial. And in doing so, you will confirm every rumour, every whispered fear about the Ministry's persecution of those who disagree with you. You will make me a martyr and yourself a tyrant." Dumbledore's voice was gentle, almost kind. "Or you can accept that you have been misled. You can return to London, issue a statement that the investigation found nothing of consequence, and allow us all to move forward."
"And let you walk free? After everything?"
"I have walked free for over a century, Cornelius. I do not intend to stop now." Dumbledore smiled, and there was no warmth in it. "But I offer you this much: I will leave Hogwarts. Temporarily."
The room went silent.
Harry's heart stopped. "No—"
"Quiet, Harry." Dumbledore didn't look at him. "The Ministry needs a victory. A symbol. My departure, voluntary and without resistance, provides that. In return, no student will be punished for tonight's events. No expulsions. No further investigations. The matter is closed."
Fudge's eyes narrowed. He was calculating, weighing the offer. Umbridge looked frantic—this wasn't what she wanted. She wanted blood, scalps, the complete destruction of her enemies.
"If you leave," Fudge said slowly, "you forfeit your position as Headmaster. Permanently."
"Those would be the terms, yes."
"And you accept that the Ministry's authority over Hogwarts is absolute."
Dumbledore's smile didn't waver. "I accept that you believe it to be so."
Fudge considered. Then, slowly, a triumphant smile spread across his face. "Done. Write your resignation. Now."
"Professor, no!" Harry surged forward, but Professor McGonagall's hand closed on his arm like a vice.
"Harry, don't," she whispered, her voice strained.
Elian set down his teacup. He had not moved, had not spoken through the entire exchange, but Harry felt his attention sharpen.
Dumbledore moved to his desk, produced a parchment and quill, and wrote swiftly. He sanded the ink, blew it dry, and handed the document to Fudge with a slight bow.
"There. Satisfied?"
Fudge read it, his smile widening. "Perfectly." He folded the parchment and tucked it into his robes. "Well. I believe our business here is concluded. Dolores?"
Umbridge looked from Fudge to Dumbledore to Harry, her expression a war of emotions. She had won—hadn't she? Dumbledore was leaving. But somehow, it felt like a loss.
"Come along," Fudge said, heading for the door. "We have a statement to prepare."
The Aurors filed out after him. Kingsley, passing Elian, gave him a long, measuring look—then nodded once, almost imperceptibly, and was gone.
Umbridge lingered. "This isn't over, Potter. Thorne. I'll be watching. Every moment. One mistake, one slip, and I'll have you both."
She swept out, the door closing behind her with a final click.
Silence.
Then Harry exploded. "Professor, you can't! You can't just—they'll ruin everything! Without you—"
Dumbledore held up a hand, and Harry's words died in his throat. The headmaster looked tired now, the public mask slipping to reveal the old man beneath.
"Harry, it is only temporary. There are things I must do, places I must go, that cannot be done from this office. The Ministry's… obsession with me has become a distraction. Without me here, they will focus elsewhere. On you, perhaps. On Elian." His eyes moved to the boy on the sofa. "Which brings me to a request."
Elian looked up. His face gave nothing away.
Dumbledore moved to stand before him. "I have watched you, Elian. From the moment Professor McGonagall found your name on that list, I have watched. I have seen you grow, adapt, prepare. I have seen you do things no wizard of your age should be capable of." He paused. "And tonight, I suspect, you have done something extraordinary in those mountains."
Elian said nothing, but something flickered in his eyes.
"I do not know what the coming months will bring," Dumbledore continued. "I know that Voldemort moves toward his goal. I know that the Ministry will grow more desperate, more repressive. And I know that I will not always be here to guide, to protect."
He placed a hand on Elian's shoulder—a gesture of such simple, human connection that it seemed almost out of place in this room of power and politics.
"So I ask you this, Elian. Not as Headmaster to student, but as one who bears a great burden to another who must learn to bear his own." His blue eyes, still twinkling, held Elian's grey ones. "Can you help me take care of them? Harry. Hermione. Ron. All of them. When I cannot."
The request hung in the air, simple and immense.
Harry felt his throat tighten. Take care of them. Like they were children. Like they needed protecting. But looking at Elian—at the strange, unreadable calm in his face, at the weight that seemed to cling to him like a second cloak—Harry understood.
Something had changed tonight. Something fundamental. And Dumbledore, in his infinite, frustrating wisdom, had seen it coming.
Elian held Dumbledore's gaze for a long moment. Then, slowly, he nodded.
"I will."
Two words. Simple. Absolute.
Dumbledore smiled—a real smile, warm and relieved. "Thank you, Elian. That is all I needed to hear."
He turned to Harry, to Professor McGonagall, to the room at large. "Now. I believe we all have much to do, and little time to do it. Minerva, would you see Harry back to Gryffindor Tower? And Elian—" He paused. "Perhaps you would stay a moment longer. I would hear of your journey."
Professor McGonagall nodded stiffly, her face pale but composed. She took Harry's arm and guided him toward the door.
Harry looked back once, seeing Elian and Dumbledore alone in the firelit office, two figures bound by secrets and purpose.
Then the door closed, and he was left with only questions.
In the silence of the headmaster's office, Dumbledore returned to his chair. Elian remained on the sofa.
"So," Dumbledore said quietly. "The giants."
Elian nodded. "Korg is dead. Twenty others. The rest have submitted."
Dumbledore absorbed this without visible reaction. "And Grawp?"
"Chieftain in name. Hermione will manage him. The giants will follow—through fear, if nothing else."
"And Voldemort's alliance?"
"Broken. His emissaries will find no army waiting."
Dumbledore was silent for a long moment, staring into the fire. When he spoke, his voice was very soft. "You have done in one night what the Order could not do in months. What I could not do."
"You could have," Elian said. "If you had chosen to."
"Perhaps." Dumbledore's smile was sad. "But I have made different choices, Elian. For better or worse. I have tried to fight this war with wisdom, with patience, with the belief that the old ways still have value." He looked at Elian. "You are proving that they may not. That a new way is needed."
Elian said nothing.
"I do not know if your path is the right one," Dumbledore continued. "I do not know if the cost—the blood, the fear, the transformation of allies into subjects—will be worth the victory it purchases. But I know that I cannot walk it. And I know that someone must."
He rose, moving to the window, looking out at the darkened grounds.
"So I will go into exile, Elian. I will hunt Horcruxes and seek answers. And you will stay here, and grow, and prepare. And when the final battle comes—as it will, sooner than any of us expect—we will meet again."
He turned back, and in his eyes was something Elian had rarely seen: vulnerability.
"Take care of them, Elian. Not as soldiers. Not as subjects. As people. As children who deserve to survive this war and live the lives they were meant to live."
Elian rose. He crossed to the door, then paused, looking back.
"I will."
He left.
Dumbledore stood alone in his office, surrounded by the whispering portraits of dead headmasters, and wondered if he had just made the greatest mistake of his long life—or the only choice that could save them all.
(End of Chapter)
✨If you're enjoying this story, consider supporting me on Patreon —
Patreon.com/TofuChan
Where you can read Extra Advance Chaters
Bonus Chapter For Every 100 Power Stones
Lets hit the goal of 300 Patreon Members now for 5 Extra Chapters 💕