Chapter 138: The Memory Charm
Marietta Edgecombe stood in the centre of the headmaster's office like a broken doll, her fingers still clutching the fabric of her robes, her eyes fixed on some distant, invisible point. The purple pustules spelling 'SNEAK' across her face had faded slightly, but the word remained, a permanent brand of her betrayal.
Fudge was apoplectic. His round face had progressed from ruddy to purple, and a vein throbbed alarmingly at his temple. "This is absurd! Dolores, you assured me—you guaranteed—that this girl would provide irrefutable evidence! And now she stands here shaking her head like a simpleton!"
"I don't understand it, Minister!" Umbridge's voice had lost its sugary coating; it was shrill, desperate. "She came to me! She told me everything! The meetings, the teaching, the coins—she was eager to tell me!"
"Perhaps," Dumbledore said mildly, "Miss Edgecombe's conscience reasserted itself. Such things happen, even to those who have temporarily lost their way."
Umbridge rounded on him, her toad-like face contorted with fury. "This is your doing! Some trick, some manipulation—"
"Professor Umbridge." Dumbledore's voice carried no heat, yet it cut through her outburst like a blade through silk. "You are making very serious accusations without a shred of evidence. I have not left this chair since Minister Fudge arrived. Are you suggesting I have some form of… remote influence over this young woman's mind?"
The implication hung in the air. Dark magic. Mind control. The very things Umbridge had spent the year accusing Dumbledore of practicing.
"I'm suggesting nothing," she hissed. "I'm stating facts. This girl confessed. Now she recants. Something happened between then and now."
Harry, standing rigidly beside Dumbledore's desk, watched the exchange with a mixture of relief and growing unease. Something was wrong with Marietta. He knew her—not well, but enough to recognize that this blank, almost serene expression was utterly foreign to her usual anxious, fluttering demeanour. It was as if someone had…
A memory surfaced. Fourth year. The Third Task. A maze, and a man who wasn't a man, and the cold sensation of something slipping away from inside his skull.
Imperius? No. The Imperius Curse left the victim dazed, suggestible. This was different. Cleaner. Like someone had taken an eraser to a chalkboard.
He glanced at Dumbledore. The Headmaster's expression was serene, but his blue eyes—Harry caught the barest flicker in them. Knowledge. Perhaps even approval.
His gaze swept the room, past the muttering portraits, past Fudge's spluttering indignation, past Umbridge's trembling rage. It landed on the Auror standing near the door—tall, bald, dark-skinned, utterly still. Kingsley Shacklebolt.
The Auror met Harry's eyes for a fraction of a second. His face betrayed nothing. But Harry felt it, a silent current of understanding.
Order of the Phoenix.
He looked away quickly, his heart hammering. Kingsley modified her memory. He made her forget. Or… changed what she remembered. That's why she's shaking her head. She genuinely doesn't remember confessing.
The realisation was both a relief and a cold shock. This was what the Order did. What they had to do. Marietta had made her choice, and now she was paying the price—not just in purple pustules, but in the theft of her own memories.
Was it right? Harry didn't know. But as he watched Umbridge's carefully constructed case crumbling to dust, he found it very hard to care.
Umbridge, however, was not finished.
She had spent a year consolidating power at Hogwarts. She had issued decrees, dismissed professors, tortured students. She had staked her reputation—and the Minister's favour—on breaking Dumbledore and exposing the rot she was certain festered beneath Hogwarts' genteel surface.
She would not let it end here.
"Minister," she said, and her voice had regained its composure, though her hands still trembled slightly. "I have another witness. One whose testimony cannot be so easily… modified."
Fudge's eyes narrowed. "Another witness? You didn't mention—"
"Because I wished to give Miss Edgecombe the opportunity to redeem herself," Umbridge lied smoothly. "But since she has chosen to obstruct this investigation, I have no choice but to call upon Mr. Malfoy."
She turned to the door, where Draco Malfoy had been hovering, watching the proceedings with barely concealed glee. At Umbridge's gesture, he stepped forward, his pointed chin raised, his expression one of pure, vindicated superiority.
"Mr. Malfoy," Umbridge said, her voice dripping with false warmth. "You were instrumental in apprehending Mr. Potter tonight. Please tell the Minister what you witnessed."
Draco's grey eyes swept the room, lingering with particular satisfaction on Harry. "Well, Minister, I was patrolling the corridors—as a member of the Inquisitorial Squad, it's my duty—when I observed suspicious activity near the seventh floor. Several students were running from the area. I apprehended Potter attempting to flee."
"Running from what, precisely?" Fudge demanded.
"The Room of Requirement. It's a known gathering place for illegal activities." Draco's smile was thin and cold. "Potter and his friends have been using it for months. They call themselves Dumbledore's Army."
The name hung in the air, damning and undeniable.
Fudge rounded on Harry. "You admit this? You formed an illegal student organisation, in direct violation of Educational Decree Number Twenty-Four?"
Harry's mouth opened, but no sound came out. What could he say? Deny it, and Malfoy would produce the coin, the parchment, the testimony of half a dozen Slytherins. Admit it, and he was expelled.
"A name, Minister," Dumbledore said calmly, "is not evidence. Hogwarts students are, as you know, prone to fanciful titles for their study groups. I recall, in my own youth, a 'Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare'—"
"This is different, and you know it!" Umbridge snapped. "This is a military organisation, Dumbledore! You are raising a private army against the Ministry!"
"An army," Dumbledore repeated, his tone mildly curious. "With what weapons, precisely? I have seen no armaments. No fortifications. I see only a group of young people who wished to practice defensive magic—a subject, I might add, that this school has been woefully unable to teach since the Ministry saw fit to interfere with my staffing decisions."
The accusation was oblique but unmistakable. Fudge flushed.
"We have not interfered—the placement of Defence professors is entirely within the Board of Governors' purview—"
"And yet," Dumbledore continued, as if Fudge hadn't spoken, "the Ministry saw fit to appoint a High Inquisitor with the power to dismiss teachers, issue binding educational decrees, and judge the fitness of this institution's curriculum. Surely, Cornelius, you can understand why some of our students might feel… inadequately prepared for the dangers of the world beyond these walls."
Fudge's mouth opened and closed soundlessly.
Umbridge, sensing her advantage slipping, played her final card. "The Ministry has not forgotten, Minister, that Dumbledore has repeatedly and publicly asserted the return of He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named. These claims have caused widespread panic and undermined the stability of our society. If he is now found to be training students in combat magic, using the spectre of a long-defeated Dark Lord as justification…"
She let the implication hang. Treason. Sedition. Open rebellion against the Ministry.
The silence in the room was absolute. The portraits had stopped whispering. Even the fire seemed to burn more quietly.
Dumbledore regarded Umbridge with something that might have been pity. "You have built your case on the testimony of a girl who no longer supports it, and a boy whose family's loyalty to the Ministry is, shall we say, a matter of recent public record. You have no physical evidence. You have no credible witnesses. You have only your certainty, Professor, and certainty is not proof."
He rose from his chair, and suddenly the room seemed smaller, his presence filling every corner. "I will make you an offer, Cornelius. Conduct a full investigation. Bring in unbiased interrogators. Use Veritaserum, if you wish. If you find that I have in any way encouraged or sanctioned the formation of an illegal military organisation, I will accept whatever punishment the Ministry deems appropriate."
He paused. His blue eyes, still twinkling, held Fudge's gaze.
"But if you find, as I suspect you will, that a group of children simply wished to learn how to defend themselves from a threat their government refuses to acknowledge… then I expect a full apology. Delivered in person. To every student you have accused."
Fudge wavered. Harry could see it—the Minister's certainty, already shaken by Marietta's recantation, crumbling further under Dumbledore's calm, relentless pressure. He didn't want an investigation. He didn't want the truth. He wanted this to go away.
"I think," Fudge said slowly, "that further investigation may be… premature. There are, as you say, issues with the witness testimony. Perhaps the matter can be resolved internally, at the school level."
Umbridge made a sound like a punctured lung. "Minister! You cannot—"
"I can, and I will," Fudge snapped. He was tired, Harry realised. Tired of chasing shadows, tired of Dumbledore's quiet superiority, tired of the mess Umbridge had dragged him into. "Professor Umbridge, I expect a full report on this matter by the end of the week. With evidence. Actual, verifiable evidence."
He turned to Dumbledore, his expression sour. "This is not over."
"It never is, Cornelius," Dumbledore said mildly. "Good evening."
Fudge stalked from the room, the Aurors falling in behind him. Kingsley Shacklebolt, passing Harry, gave him the barest nod—almost imperceptible, but there. Stay strong, it said. We are with you.
Umbridge lingered, her eyes burning with thwarted fury. She looked at Harry, at Dumbledore, at the door through which her victory had just vanished.
"This isn't over," she whispered. "I will have you both."
Then she was gone, Draco Malfoy scurrying after her like a well-trained dog.
The door closed. The fire crackled. The portraits began to mutter again, their whispers filling the sudden silence.
Harry let out a breath he hadn't realised he'd been holding. His legs felt weak. "Professor… what just happened?"
Dumbledore lowered himself back into his chair. He looked, Harry thought, profoundly weary. "A reprieve, Harry. Nothing more. Professor Umbridge will not stop. Minister Fudge will not acknowledge the truth. And we have bought ourselves only a little time."
"A little time for what?"
Dumbledore's eyes met his. "For the storm to arrive. For answers to be found. For Elian Thorne to return from the mountains with whatever news he bears."
He glanced at the window, at the darkness beyond. "Which, if I am not mistaken, he has just done."
Harry followed his gaze, but saw nothing—only the distant, lighted towers of Hogwarts, and the deeper darkness of the Forbidden Forest beyond.
Somewhere out there, a boy who had left as a student was returning as something else entirely.
And the war, Harry realised, was only just beginning.
(End of Chapter)
✨If you're enjoying this story, consider supporting me on Patreon —
Patreon.com/TofuChan
Where you can read Extra Advance Chaters
Bonus Chapter For Every 100 Power Stones
Lets hit the goal of 300 Patreon Members now for 5 Extra Chapters 💕