WebNovels

Chapter 11 - Chapter 11: Evaluations

Support me on patreon.com/c/Striker2025

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The staff meeting convened in the small conference room adjacent to Dumbledore's office, a circular space lined with portraits of former headmasters who watched the proceedings with varying degrees of interest. Candles floated overhead, casting warm light on the polished wooden table where the Hogwarts faculty had gathered for their monthly assessment.

Dumbledore sat at the head of the table, his blue eyes twinkling behind half-moon spectacles as he surveyed his staff. "Now then, let us discuss this year's students. How are our first-years progressing?"

Professor McGonagall consulted her notes first. "Overall, a competent group. Miss Hartwell shows promise in Transfiguration, though she tends toward recklessness. Mr. Boot demonstrates solid fundamentals. Miss Chen has excellent theoretical understanding but lacks confidence in practical application."

"And Mr. Kael?" Dumbledore asked mildly.

McGonagall's lips tightened slightly. "Exceptional. Perhaps too much so. His spell work is approaching second-year level, and his theoretical knowledge appears far beyond his years."

Professor Flitwick leaned forward eagerly. "I must concur. The boy has demonstrated remarkable aptitude for spell modification—something I've never encountered in a first-year. He's created several novel charm combinations that show genuine innovation."

"Ah yes," Dumbledore nodded. "I understand he's made quite an impression on you, Filius."

"Indeed. Though I must admit some concern about the advanced nature of his experimentation. Such work typically requires years of theoretical foundation."

Professor Snape spoke from the shadows at the table's far end. "The boy possesses unusual theoretical knowledge in Potions as well. He successfully modified a Sleeping Draught recipe using advanced substitution techniques. When questioned about his sources, he claimed to have learned from 'extensive reading.'"

"His reading habits are certainly... comprehensive," added Madam Pince. "I've observed him checking out texts that most N.E.W.T. students would find challenging. He appears to absorb information at an extraordinary rate."

Professor Merrythought, the elderly Defense instructor, tapped her quill thoughtfully. "In my classes, he demonstrates tactical thinking that suggests real understanding of magical combat theory. Not just memorization—genuine comprehension of strategy and application."

Dumbledore steepled his fingers, his expression thoughtful. "Most interesting. And his character? How does he interact with his peers?"

"Well-regarded among his housemates," McGonagall reported. "He's formed friendships across house lines and recently defended a younger Hufflepuff from bullying, though the confrontation resulted in magical combat with three older Slytherins."

"He won?" Professor Sprout asked with surprise.

"Decisively," McGonagall confirmed. "Using tactics that were both creative and effective."

Dumbledore was quiet for a long moment, his blue eyes distant. The other professors exchanged glances, recognizing the signs of their headmaster's deep contemplation.

"Albus?" McGonagall prompted gently.

"Forgive me," Dumbledore said, returning to the present. "It's simply that such exceptional ability combined with advanced theoretical knowledge reminds me of another student, many years ago."

The temperature in the room seemed to drop. Everyone understood the reference.

"You don't think—" Flitwick began.

"I think nothing yet," Dumbledore said firmly. "But I believe it would be prudent to speak with young Mr. Kael directly. Understanding the source of his exceptional abilities—and more importantly, his intentions—seems wise."

After the meeting concluded and the professors had departed, Dumbledore sat alone in his office, staring into the dancing flames of his fireplace. The portraits around the walls stirred quietly, sensing his contemplative mood.

"Troubled thoughts, Albus?" asked the portrait of Phineas Nigellus Black.

"Perhaps. We have a student of unusual ability—one whose knowledge and skill far exceed what should be possible for his age and experience."

"Another prodigy," Black observed. "Hogwarts has seen many."

"Yes, but few with such comprehensive advancement across multiple disciplines. It reminds me uncomfortably of Tom Riddle's early years."

"You fear another Dark Lord in the making?"

Dumbledore considered this carefully. "I fear the possibility. Exceptional ability without proper moral foundation has led to tragedy before. I must assess not just what this boy can do, but what he will choose to do with his gifts."

The summons came during dinner two days later. Professor McGonagall approached the Ravenclaw table with her usual brisk efficiency.

"Mr. Kael, Professor Dumbledore would like to see you in his office after the meal. Password is 'Fizzing Whizbees.'"

Sarah looked up from her shepherd's pie with concern. "Are you in trouble?"

"I don't think so," Darius replied, though his mind was racing. Why would Dumbledore want to see him personally?

[Assessment: Multiple possibilities. Faculty reports likely prompted headmaster attention. Recommend cautious approach.]

The gargoyle stepped aside at his password, revealing the spiral staircase to Dumbledore's office. Darius climbed slowly, using the time to prepare mentally for whatever awaited him.

He knocked on the office door and heard Dumbledore's familiar voice call, "Enter."

The office was exactly as he remembered from the films—circular walls lined with portraits, silver instruments whirring and clicking, and behind an enormous desk, Albus Dumbledore himself. The wizard looked exactly as Darius had imagined: tall, thin, with long silver hair and beard, wearing robes of deep purple. But it was the eyes that commanded attention—brilliant blue and far too perceptive for comfort.

"Ah, Mr. Kael. Please, sit down." Dumbledore gestured to a comfortable chair before his desk. "Lemon drop?"

"No thank you, Professor."

Dumbledore settled back in his own chair, studying Darius with those penetrating blue eyes. The silence stretched for nearly a minute before the headmaster spoke.

"Tell me, how are you finding Hogwarts?"

"It's wonderful, sir. Better than I ever imagined."

"And your studies? I understand you've made quite remarkable progress in several subjects."

Darius felt his pulse quicken. "I enjoy learning, Professor. Magic is... fascinating."

"Indeed it is. Professor Snape tells me you successfully modified a Sleeping Draught recipe using advanced substitution techniques. Professor Flitwick reports you've created several novel charm combinations. Such achievements are unusual for a first-year student."

There was no accusation in Dumbledore's tone, merely curiosity, but Darius sensed deeper currents beneath the gentle questioning.

"I read extensively, sir. I find that understanding the theory behind spells makes the practical application much easier."

"Admirable. And where did you encounter the theoretical knowledge necessary for such modifications?"

This was the crucial question. Darius had prepared for it, but facing Dumbledore's knowing gaze, he felt exposed in a way the nano machine couldn't help him with.

"The library, mostly. Advanced texts that most students don't consult. I've always been drawn to understanding how things work at a fundamental level."

Dumbledore nodded slowly. "Professor Flitwick showed me documentation of your spell modifications. The theoretical framework underlying your innovations suggests not just broad reading, but deep comprehension of magical principles. Such understanding typically requires years of study and experience."

"Perhaps I have good instincts for magical theory, sir."

"Perhaps." Dumbledore leaned forward slightly. "Tell me, what do you hope to accomplish with your magical education?"

The question caught Darius off guard. Not what career he wanted, or which subjects interested him most, but what he hoped to accomplish. As if Dumbledore sensed there was a larger purpose behind his intense study.

"I want to understand magic completely," Darius said honestly. "How it works, why it works, what its limitations are. And I want to use that knowledge to help people."

"Help them how?"

"Protect them. Magic is dangerous—there are dark wizards, dangerous creatures, curses that can destroy lives. If I can become skilled enough, knowledgeable enough, maybe I can make a difference when it matters."

Dumbledore's expression didn't change, but something flickered in his blue eyes. "A noble goal. Though one might ask why an eleven-year-old boy feels such responsibility for protecting others."

Darius met his gaze steadily. "Because I've seen what happens when no one does."

They sat in silence for several moments, Dumbledore studying Darius with an intensity that made him feel transparent. Finally, the headmaster smiled—a genuine expression of warmth.

"I believe, Mr. Kael, that your research deserves wider recognition. Would you be interested in documenting your potion modifications for publication in Potions Quarterly? Such work could earn you a Young Innovator's Award from the International Confederation of Wizards."

Darius blinked in surprise. "You think my work is good enough for publication?"

"I think your work demonstrates genuine innovation and practical value. With proper documentation and theoretical explanation, it would make a valuable contribution to the field." Dumbledore's eyes twinkled. "Though I would suggest collaborating with Professor Snape to ensure proper presentation."

"I... yes, sir. I'd be honored."

"Excellent. I'll speak with Professor Snape about the details." Dumbledore stood, indicating the meeting was concluding. "Continue your studies, Mr. Kael. And remember—with great ability comes great responsibility to use it wisely."

As Darius left the office, his mind reeled from the encounter. Publication? An award? It seemed impossible, but Dumbledore's interest felt genuine.

[Assessment: Favorable outcome. Headmaster approval secured. Academic advancement opportunity presented.]

But as he walked back toward Ravenclaw Tower, he couldn't shake the feeling that the entire conversation had been a test—one whose true purpose remained hidden.

After the office door closed behind Darius, Dumbledore remained standing, staring thoughtfully at the space where the boy had sat. Several of the portraits stirred, sensing his contemplative mood.

"Well?" asked the portrait of Dilys Derwent. "What's your assessment?"

Dumbledore moved to the window, gazing out at the darkened grounds. "Remarkable ability, certainly. Knowledge that far exceeds his apparent experience. But more importantly, clear moral conviction. When I pressed him about his motivations, his answers rang true."

"You mentioned Tom Riddle earlier," said Phineas Nigellus Black. "Do you still see similarities?"

"In ability, yes. Both possessed exceptional magical talent and accelerated learning. But Tom's motivations, even as a child, centered on power and control. Mr. Kael spoke of protecting others, of taking responsibility." Dumbledore paused. "Tom never spoke of helping anyone but himself."

"Still," Black persisted, "such ability combined with secretive behavior..."

"Is worth monitoring," Dumbledore agreed. "But not condemning. The boy has shown no signs of the casual cruelty or manipulative behavior that marked Tom's early years. Indeed, his defense of a younger student suggests the opposite."

"You'll keep watching him?"

"Naturally. But I will watch with hope rather than fear." Dumbledore returned to his desk and sat down heavily. "We have seen what becomes of exceptional magical ability guided by selfishness and ambition. Perhaps now we shall see what becomes of such ability guided by compassion and responsibility."

He reached for his quill and began writing a letter to the editor of Potions Quarterly. Whatever secrets young Darius Kael might be hiding, his heart seemed to be in the right place. And in these times, with dark forces stirring beyond the school's walls, Hogwarts could use all the protective power it could find—regardless of how unusual its source might be.

Above him, the portraits of former headmasters watched and whispered among themselves, adding another chapter to the long history of exceptional students who had walked these halls. Some had become great heroes. Others had become terrible villains.

Only time would reveal which path Darius D. Kael would choose to walk.

More Chapters