Chapter 452: Forced into Peril (Part II)
"Yes, there is only one person in the world with dragons—everyone knows that!" Rickard was momentarily stunned by Egger's righteous admission. It took him a few seconds to regain his bearings. "Then I must ask: how did a man of the Night's Watch end up with the Mad King's spawn?"
"The Dragon Queen specifically rushed from the battlefields of King's Landing to the front lines of the Gift. She personally rode her dragon to join the Night's Watch in pursuing the enemy that had bypassed the Wall. Not only did she help us annihilate the foe, but she saved hundreds, if not thousands, of Northmen from the jaws of death—including your own liege, Robb Stark. To do so, she sacrificed one of her three dragons and another heavily wounded. Only one dragon just flew over this castle; did you not stop to wonder why?"
"Perhaps the Queen only had one dragon to begin with, and the talk of three was just a rumor. Or perhaps there are three, but only one showed up—who knows?" The son, whose age was hard to discern behind a thick beard, spoke with a hostile tone. "You claim this Queen abandoned King's Landing to protect the North and save Robb Stark? Then why has no one from Winterfell come with you to inform me? The Others stand on the ground; how could they harm a dragon in the sky? Do you think because we look like rough men, we must be brainless enough for you to deceive?"
This son of Rickard stood nearly one hundred and ninety centimeters tall and was built like a bear. Already massive, he was clad in thick furs and armor; Egger had no doubt that two of himself could only manage a draw against him—and that was assuming they were unarmed. Maintaining composure and a calm mind to find a way out while under the fierce gaze of such a giant was no easy feat, but Egger was well-acquainted with high-stakes pressure.
The Others left no corpses when they died, and the wights and the white dragon had already been burned where they fell. Egger truly had no physical evidence to present, yet he stood tall and unmoving. "Whether this is true or not, you are free to question the Night's Watchmen, the New Gift settlers, or the Mountain Clansmen returning with me. The truth cannot be hidden, and a lie cannot be made real. Now, the Queen's injured black dragon desperately needs a safe environment to recover. That is why she followed me north after the great battle, hoping to borrow Last Hearth—which we believed to be empty. We did not expect your army to occupy it first. It is for this reason that I came on her behalf to persuade you to return to Karhold, so as to avoid conflict."
The escorting Night's Watchmen chimed in to testify for their Lord Commander, but their voices carried little weight; the two Karstarks ignored them entirely.
"Avoid conflict? You talk a fine game! No wonder you were being so secretive and evasive earlier, trying so hard to convince me to leave. You wanted to trick me into handing Last Hearth to the Mad King's daughter on a silver platter, giving her an easy first trophy in the North!" Rickard exploded into a rage again. He was naturally short-tempered, but being jerked up and down like a roller coaster by Egger was a rare experience even for him. "The land of the Northmen is no place for outsiders to meddle! Even if we all die here today and are burned to ash by dragonflame, we will never let her set foot in this castle! You've miscalculated. Guards!"
If a dozen Night's Watchmen might have had a chance to fight their way out in the chaos, that chance vanished as twenty or thirty soldiers swarmed in at the Karstark lord's thunderous roar. His son also placed a hand on his weapon with a cold sneer. Egger had no retreat; he could only move forward.
He couldn't afford more small talk. If he delayed until Rickard gave the order to seize him, it would be too late.
...
"Are you Harrion Karstark?" Egger turned to ask the middle-aged bearded man.
The man smirked. "Heh, a bit late to try and act friendly, isn't it? Go to the dungeon and reflect on your choices!"
Egger raised a hand to signal him to wait. "Ser Harrion, allow me to make a bold guess—is your brother, Torrhen Karstark, also within this castle?"
"What if he is? I don't recall him having any friendship with the likes of you."
Friendship? Egger wasn't counting on that. He was betting on one thing: A leopard doesn't change its spots. Rickard's habit of bringing all his sons with him to war was a flaw he wouldn't have corrected.
The old man's youngest son, Eddard Karstark, had already been killed by Euron Greyjoy during the fighting on the west coast. This meant that if Harrion and Torrhen were both here, then Rickard Karstark—the man himself and all his male heirs—were contained within this single small castle.
Many tough men do not fear death, but when their sons are trapped in the same snare, not everyone can summon the courage to die together. For these ancient houses, nothing was more important than the survival of the bloodline.
"I am indeed not well-acquainted with your brother; I might not even recognize him if he stood before me," Egger smiled with forced ease. "But tell me, my lords: do the walls of Last Hearth look thicker or more fireproof than those of Harrenhal?"
Under normal circumstances, Egger would never be stupid enough to use threats against these typical Northern brutes. But now, the Queen's brainless display of force had left him with no choice but to use it as his only leverage in a desperate situation.
By asking Harrion about his brother and then immediately mentioning Harrenhal, Egger wasn't just citing the most famous castle destroyed by dragonflame. He was referencing how the last King of the Isles and the Rivers died along with his entire line while trying to hold a stronghold against dragons. The Hoare family vanished from the world forever. If Rickard and his only two remaining sons were all in this castle, the fate of Harren the Black and his failed heroism would surely make him associate his current situation with that history—forcing him to calm down and weigh the costs.
"You bastard, do you truly not fear death?" Harrion, despite his large beard, was only a few years older than Egger. In the prime of his life and full of youthful vigor, he was instantly incensed by the threat. He drew his longsword with a sharp shing. "Even if the three of us fall here today, I still have my sister, my uncles, and my cousins at Karhold! As for you—I want to see how the Queen's dragon can save you from my blade!"
Now, it all depended on whether Rickard's love for his sons was as strong as Egger judged it to be.
Egger didn't dare engage and let the situation spiral out of control. He took a step back, and several well-trained Night's Watch soldiers immediately understood, raising their weapons to stand between their commander and the furious Harrion. They weren't one hundred and ninety centimeters tall or two hundred pounds, but those selected for the guard were neither small nor cowardly. Until the surrounding Karstark soldiers received a direct order from their lord to attack, a single man could not threaten the Lord Commander.
"Harrion, get back!"
Just as the young noble hesitated for a second over whether to strike the other innocent Watchmen, and just as Egger's heart climbed into his throat, Rickard spoke up to stop his son. He reached out an arm to shove Harrion behind him and walked up to Egger, staring him down with irrepressible fury.
If Egger were alone and dared to threaten him to his face, Rickard Karstark would have taken his head without a second word. But this time, with his only two remaining sons inside the castle and having no weapons or plan to deal with a dragon, Egger had successfully seized his weakness. Rickard dared not act rashly. House Karstark certainly had more than these three men, but the Queen's dragon could fly, and Last Hearth had no scorpions. Once the Mad King's daughter was provoked, anything could happen.
"A fine Lord Commander of the Night's Watch you are. Seeing no room for promotion at the Wall, you found yourself a better path—well done! That Targaryen little b*tch is mad for the Iron Throne and takes anyone who defects... Hah! Recruiting the Night's Watch! Only she would be crude enough to think of that." Rickard gritted his teeth, speaking through a mountain of murderous intent. "I am curious, though: if I seize you now and lock you in the dungeon beneath this hall, how would she dare use her dragon against me?"
If that happened, everything would fall apart.
A chill ran down Egger's spine. If he were seized, the Gift's army would be leaderless, and the Queen would have no authority over them. If she burned the castle out of desperation to destroy the Karstarks, no one else would have Egger's prestige or charisma to hold the Gift together for the coming war against their former Northern allies. The Mountain Clans, the New Gift settlers, and the Night's Watch would scatter. No one would lead the transport team to bring the injured black dragon into the castle. He would lose his life, and the Queen would lose her mount and be stranded in the North to die. His "Grand Crownlands" plan and his goal to break the wheel of history would all become a joke.
"Hahahaha..."
The more his weakness was touched, the harder he had to act. Showing fear or begging for mercy now would be the end.
Egger laughed and stretched out his hands as if surrendering. "My lord, either kill me immediately or pray you lock me in the deepest dungeon possible; I have no desire to feel the touch of dragonflame. Do you think the Queen cares for the life of a single Night's Watchman? She is merely in a hurry to find a castle for her precious, wounded black dragon to heal. She explicitly told me: if I am in this castle for an hour and do not come out, she is to wash every corner of this fortress with dragonflame. I understand your opposition to the Watch breaking neutrality, but imagine this story: The dragons and the Watch joined forces to repel and destroy the Others invading the North. The Karstark army not only failed to help, but turned around and stabbed the Watch in the back. They killed the greatest hero—me, the Lord Commander—and provoked the Queen who traveled thousands of miles to help, resulting in thousands of pointless deaths, including the current Lord Karstark and all his sons..."
"It sounds like a farce, doesn't it?" He gave Rickard no time to think or stay angry, immediately continuing to direct the narrative. "If you don't want to become a laughingstock and a cautionary tale for the Seven Kingdoms and future generations, then I ask you to calm down and listen to my envisioned 'happily-ever-after' version of this story."
While both are attempts at persuasion, the biggest difference between a bluff and a threat is that failing a bluff usually doesn't change much, but failing a threat usually ends in disaster.
Tense cold sweat was beginning to soak the shirt beneath his vest. The situation had not yet spiraled out of control, but Egger knew it wasn't time to relax. To get a hard man like Rickard Karstark to back down and retreat in shame, threatening his sons' lives wasn't enough. Beyond the stick, he needed a carrot—he had to make Rickard feel that while he was losing out, he still had a graceful way to exit. Only then would he have a chance of succeeding.
Support me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/MistaQuartz
On Patreon, you can explore Extra Chapters in advance!
