Chapter 28: The Benders
[Hibbing, Minnesota — December 5, 2005, Afternoon]
Sam was supposed to check in thirty minutes ago.
Ethan stood beside the Impala, phone pressed to his ear, listening to the call go straight to voicemail for the sixth time. Dean paced beside him, jaw tight, hands curling and uncurling into fists.
"He was just doing recon," Dean said. "Talking to witnesses, getting background on the disappearances. That's it."
"I know."
"He should have called by now."
"I know."
Ethan's Sin Sense swept the area for the hundredth time, searching for any trace of supernatural activity. Nothing. No demonic presence, no ghostly residue, no monster signature of any kind. Whatever had happened to Sam Winchester, it hadn't been caused by the things they usually hunted.
That scared Ethan more than demons ever could.
"We retrace his route," Ethan said. "Every stop, every witness, every location he was supposed to visit. If someone saw something—"
"What if it wasn't someone? What if it was some THING?"
"Then my senses would have picked it up." Ethan met Dean's eyes. "This wasn't supernatural, Dean. This was human."
The words hung in the air between them, heavy with implication. Human predators. Human evil. The kind of monster that didn't show up on any hunter's radar because it wore the same face as everyone else.
Dean's expression went cold. "Then we find them. And we make them wish they'd picked a different victim."
[Hibbing, Minnesota — December 5, 2005, Evening]
Deputy Kathleen Hudak met them at the sheriff's station, her professional demeanor barely containing the grief underneath. Her brother had disappeared a year ago—same pattern as the recent cases, same absence of evidence, same frustrating dead ends.
"I've been working this off the books," she said, spreading files across her desk. "My superiors think it's just runaways, drifters who moved on. But I know something's taking them."
"Taking them where?" Dean asked.
"That's what I've been trying to figure out." Kathleen pulled up a map marked with red pins. "All the disappearances happen within a twenty-mile radius. All the victims were alone, traveling through rural areas after dark. And all of them vanished without a trace."
Ethan studied the map. The pins formed a loose circle around a section of dense forest, the kind of area where someone could hide anything—or anyone—for years without being discovered.
"There's something here," he said, pointing to the center of the pattern. "Property records?"
"State forest. But there are a few private parcels grandfathered in from before the designation." Kathleen pulled another file. "One family has owned the same plot for generations. The Benders. They mostly keep to themselves—home schooled kids, rarely come into town. Local people think they're just eccentric."
"Or they're something worse."
Dean was already heading for the door. "We're checking it out. Tonight."
"I'm coming with you." Kathleen grabbed her jacket. "My brother might still be alive. If there's even a chance—"
"This isn't a police operation," Dean said. "Whatever we find out there, it won't be something you can arrest."
"I don't care." Her eyes were hard, determined. "Riley was my brother. I need to know."
Ethan recognized that look. He'd seen it in the mirror, in the days after Katie's death. The desperate need for answers, even if those answers brought more pain than peace.
"She comes," he said. "We might need the backup."
[Bender Property — December 5, 2005, Night]
The compound emerged from the forest like a wound—a collection of ramshackle buildings surrounded by rusted vehicles and the accumulated debris of a family that had stopped pretending to be civilized long ago. No lights burned in the windows. No sounds carried through the darkness.
But Ethan's Sin Sense was screaming.
Four people inside the main building. The guilt radiating from them was unlike anything he'd encountered—not the desperate shame of someone who'd made mistakes, but the cold satisfaction of predators who enjoyed what they did. They had hunted, killed, tortured, and reveled in every moment.
His hands started smoking.
"Ethan." Dean's voice was sharp. "What is it?"
"They're in there. The family." Ethan's voice came out rough, layered with the Spirit's resonance. "And they're worse than demons. At least demons have the excuse of being evil by nature. These people chose this."
"Sam?"
"I can't sense him specifically, but there are more people on the property. Underground, maybe. In cages."
Dean's face went white, then red with barely controlled fury. "Then we move. Now."
"Wait." Ethan grabbed his arm. "If we go in blind, we might get Sam killed. We need to scout first—find where they're holding him, neutralize the family, then extract."
"Since when do you counsel patience?"
"Since the alternative is getting your brother murdered by hillbilly psychopaths." Ethan's grip tightened. "Give me ten minutes to circle the property. I'll find where they're keeping the victims."
Dean wanted to argue—Ethan could see it in his eyes, the desperate need to act, to DO something instead of waiting. But tactical sense won out over emotion.
"Ten minutes. Then we go in regardless."
The barn stood fifty yards from the main house, connected by a rutted path barely visible through the overgrown grass. Ethan approached it from the tree line, moving with the silence his military training had drilled into him long before the Spirit added supernatural stealth.
Inside, he heard voices.
Not conversation—screaming. Pleading. The sound of metal on metal, like a cage door being rattled by someone desperate to escape.
His transformation triggered without conscious thought.
Fire erupted from his skin. His skull emerged through burning flesh, wreathed in Hellfire that cast dancing shadows across the barn's weathered walls. The Spirit surged forward, DEMANDING judgment, DEMANDING that Ethan enter that building and punish the evil waiting inside.
THEY HUNT HUMANS. THEY TORTURE. THEY KILL FOR SPORT. THEY ARE WORSE THAN ANY DEMON WE HAVE FACED.
"I know."
THEN WHY DO YOU HESITATE?
"Because Dean's brother is in there. And if I lose control, I might kill everyone—including Sam."
The Spirit didn't respond, but its pressure relented slightly. It understood, even if it didn't like the logic.
Ethan forced himself back to human form, the transition painful in a way it usually wasn't. The Urge was stronger here than it had ever been—stronger than the vampires in Nebraska, stronger than the demon on the plane, stronger than Meg's trap in Chicago. These were humans who had chosen evil, and the Spirit wanted them to BURN.
He circled the barn, found a side door, and slipped inside.
The interior was worse than he'd imagined. Cages lined one wall—actual cages, like something from a dog pound, but sized for humans. Three of them were occupied: an older man who might have been Kathleen's brother, a young woman with vacant eyes, and—
Sam.
He was unconscious, bleeding from a cut on his forehead, slumped against the cage's bars. But he was breathing. Alive.
Ethan's relief lasted exactly two seconds before the Benders appeared.
Four of them, emerging from the shadows like they'd been waiting. The patriarch—a huge man with a face like carved granite—held a hunting rifle. His wife carried a butcher's knife. The two sons were armed with what looked like homemade spears.
"Well, well," the patriarch said. "Another one come looking. You people never learn."
Ethan let his eyes glow orange. "You have no idea what you've caught."
"I've caught a lot of things, boy. Tracked 'em, caged 'em, hunted 'em. It's what my family does. What we've always done." The patriarch's smile was wrong—too wide, too hungry. "You look like you'd give us a good chase."
"Let me show you what a good chase looks like."
The transformation was instant—fire exploding from Ethan's body, chains manifesting from nothing, the Spirit of Vengeance rising like a phoenix from human flesh. The Benders stumbled backward, their confidence shattering against the reality of something they couldn't hunt, couldn't cage, couldn't kill.
The patriarch raised his rifle. Ethan's chain ripped it from his hands, wrapped around his throat, and dragged him forward.
"You want to see real hunting?" Ethan's voice was the Spirit's now, deep and resonant and utterly inhuman. "Look into my eyes."
The Penance Stare triggered.
The patriarch saw everything—every victim, every death, every moment of suffering he'd caused or witnessed or enjoyed. Decades of evil compressed into seconds, experienced from the perspective of those who'd suffered. His scream was raw, primal, the sound of a mind breaking under the weight of its own sins.
He collapsed, eyes open and empty, brain destroyed by the accumulated horror of his own actions.
The rest of the family tried to run.
Dean burst through the barn door, shotgun blazing. Kathleen was right behind him, her service weapon up. The mother went down first—Kathleen's bullet catching her in the chest. One son tried to attack Dean with his spear and took a face full of rock salt for his trouble.
The other son reached the back door, yanked it open, and found himself face-to-face with Ethan's transformed form.
"Please—"
"You don't get to beg." Ethan grabbed him, Hellfire searing through the boy's jacket. "You never let them beg."
Dean's hand landed on Ethan's shoulder. "We need him alive. For information. For closure." His voice was steady, reasonable, cutting through the Spirit's fury. "Sam's safe now. The hunt is over. You won."
The Spirit raged. The Urge demanded blood, demanded fire, demanded judgment for every victim the Benders had ever taken.
But Dean's hand was warm, grounding, human.
Ethan let the son go. The boy collapsed, screaming from the burns, but alive.
"Get Sam," Ethan said through gritted teeth. "I need... I need a minute."
He walked out of the barn and kept walking until the screams faded into silence.
[Impala — December 6, 2005, 2:47 AM]
Sam slept in the backseat, wounds cleaned and bandaged, exhausted from captivity but otherwise unharmed. Kathleen had stayed behind to handle the aftermath—the bodies, the survivors, the official story that would never capture the full horror of what the Benders had done.
Ethan sat on the Impala's hood, staring at nothing, feeling the Spirit settle into something approaching calm.
Dean appeared beside him, two beers in hand. "You okay?"
"No."
"Fair enough." Dean handed him a bottle. "You know, for a minute there, I thought you were going to kill all of them. Before we even got Sam out."
"I wanted to." Ethan's voice was hollow. "The Spirit wanted to. Human evil is... different. Demons are corrupted by their nature. Monsters follow instinct. But humans? Humans choose. And the Spirit doesn't forgive choices."
"But you held back."
"Barely."
"Barely still counts." Dean took a long pull from his beer. "You could've burned that whole compound to the ground the moment you sensed what they were. But you waited. You trusted me to have a plan. That means something."
"Does it?" Ethan finally looked at him. "I stood over that man's body—the patriarch—and I felt satisfied. Not relieved. Satisfied. Like destroying his mind was exactly what he deserved."
"Wasn't it?"
"Maybe. But that's not the point. The point is I ENJOYED it. And if you hadn't been there, if Sam hadn't been in danger, I would have enjoyed killing all of them." His hands were shaking. "How long before the enjoyment outweighs the restraint?"
Dean was quiet for a long moment. Then: "You know why I trust you? Why Sam trusts you? Because you ask questions like that. Monsters don't worry about becoming monsters. They just ARE."
"And if someday I stop asking?"
"Then we deal with it. Together." Dean clinked his bottle against Ethan's. "But until then? You're still one of us."
They sat in silence, drinking cheap beer under a Minnesota sky, while Sam slept and the memory of the Benders slowly faded into the darkness where it belonged.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1