Chapter 9: Dead in the Water — Part 1
[Highway 94 East — September 23, 2005, Afternoon — Wisconsin]
The Impala's engine thrummed a steady rhythm as Dean pushed the speedometer past seventy. Ethan's truck followed a car length behind, close enough to maintain visual contact, far enough to avoid looking like a convoy.
Three days since the Wendigo hunt. Three days of driving, refueling, eating at roadside diners that served coffee strong enough to dissolve spoons. The trial partnership was holding, but barely—Dean still watched Ethan like he expected him to burst into flames and attack at any moment, and Sam kept asking questions about the Spirit that Ethan couldn't fully answer.
Normal, really. As normal as anything got in this life.
The radio crackled—Dean's voice through the CB unit they'd rigged for communication. "New case. Lake Manitoc, Wisconsin. Three drownings in the past year, no bodies recovered."
"Suspicious drownings in a lake," Ethan replied. "Water spirit? Kelpie? Something else?"
"That's what we're going to find out. ETA four hours if we push it."
Four hours. Ethan's back already ached from the truck's worn suspension, and the prospect of another marathon drive made his shoulders tense in anticipation.
WATER. ANCIENT DEATHS. VENGEANCE SEEKING FORM.
"What do you mean?"
SOMETHING DIED IN THAT LAKE. SOMETHING THAT REFUSES TO REST.
Vengeful spirit, then. Ghost tied to a specific location, killing people connected to its death. Standard case, standard solution—find the remains, salt and burn, move on to the next town and the next monster.
Except nothing had been standard since Ethan woke up in a Nebraska warehouse with fire in his chest and a stranger's face in the mirror.
[Lake Manitoc, Wisconsin — September 23, 2005, Evening]
Lake Manitoc was the kind of small town that existed in postcards and nostalgic memories: main street America preserved in amber, population two thousand and falling, economy built on fishing and tourism and a stubborn refusal to admit the modern world existed.
The lake itself was beautiful—clear blue water surrounded by pine forests, dotted with vacation homes and fishing boats. The kind of place families came to escape the pressures of city life.
The kind of place where three people had drowned in the past year without their bodies ever being found.
Dean parked the Impala in front of the local sheriff's station. Ethan pulled his truck in alongside, stretching cramped muscles as he climbed out.
"Standard approach," Dean said, adjusting his tie. They'd changed into suits at a rest stop—FBI agents investigating unusual patterns in local deaths. "Sam handles the research angle. I charm the locals. You..."
"Watch and listen," Ethan finished. "Stay out of the way unless something supernatural shows up."
"Pretty much."
The sheriff's station was small, efficient, and staffed by exactly three people: a dispatcher who looked like she'd been doing the job since before television existed, a deputy who couldn't have been older than twenty-two, and Sheriff Jake Devins himself.
Devins was mid-fifties, weathered, with the kind of face that suggested he'd seen things and preferred not to discuss them. He met them in his office with the resigned patience of a man who'd dealt with federal interference before.
"Agent Tyler, Agent Perry," Devins said, nodding at the fake IDs Dean and Sam presented. His eyes lingered on Ethan. "And you are?"
"Consultant," Ethan said. "Behavioral analysis."
"Uh-huh." Devins didn't believe it for a second, but he also didn't push. Small-town law enforcement knew when to let federal agencies run their investigations without interference.
"The drownings," Sam began, settling into his research persona. "We've noticed an unusual pattern in your records. Three deaths in twelve months, all in the same area of the lake, no bodies recovered despite extensive searches."
"Tragic accidents," Devins said. "The lake's got currents that can drag a body down and keep it there."
"But the victims were experienced swimmers. Local residents who knew the water."
"Even experts make mistakes. One bad cramp, one moment of panic, and the lake takes you."
Ethan barely heard the conversation. The moment he'd stepped into the sheriff's office, his chest had started burning.
The Spirit was reacting to something—someone—in this building. Not the supernatural wrongness of a monster, but something older, more human. Guilt. Heavy, specific, connected to the deaths they were investigating.
Sheriff Devins carried sin like a physical weight.
HE KNOWS. HE HAS HIDDEN TRUTH. HE HAS LET INNOCENTS DIE RATHER THAN FACE WHAT HE HAS DONE.
Ethan gripped the edge of Devins' desk. His knuckles whitened. Heat radiated from his palms, barely contained, the Spirit demanding action.
"—and we appreciate your cooperation, Sheriff." Dean was wrapping up the interview, oblivious to Ethan's internal struggle. "We'll need access to the incident reports and any witness statements."
"Deputy Fuller can help you with that. My files are open to federal investigation." Devins stood, clearly eager to end the conversation. His eyes met Ethan's briefly—a flash of something that might have been recognition, or might have been guilt seeing its reflection.
"One more question," Ethan said. His voice came out rough, strained. "Do you know why these people died, Sheriff?"
Silence.
Devins' expression didn't change, but something shifted behind his eyes. A door closing. A mask settling into place.
"I know they drowned. I know the lake is dangerous. I know I've warned people for thirty years to be careful in those waters." His voice was steady, professional. "If you're looking for a conspiracy, Agent, you won't find one here."
The Urge screamed at Ethan to grab the man, to force him to look into burning eyes, to make him experience every death he'd helped conceal. The Spirit wanted judgment.
Ethan forced himself to let go of the desk. His hands left scorch marks on the wood—faint, but visible. Devins stared at them, then at Ethan, fear flickering across his face before he suppressed it.
"Thank you for your time, Sheriff."
They left the station in silence. Dean shot Ethan a questioning look but said nothing until they'd reached the parking lot.
"What was that about?"
"The sheriff knows something." Ethan's hands were still trembling. He shoved them in his pockets to hide it. "My... instincts went haywire around him. Whatever's killing people in that lake, he's connected to it."
Sam's eyebrows rose. "You think he's involved?"
"Not directly. But he's carrying guilt related to the deaths. Heavy guilt. The kind that comes from hiding something terrible for a long time."
"That's... specific." Dean's voice carried a warning edge. "How specific can your instinct get?"
"It tells me someone is guilty, not what they did. But Devins is hiding something. Something connected to the drownings."
Dean exchanged a look with Sam. The silent communication between brothers—weighing options, calculating risks.
"We investigate normally," Dean decided. "Research the victims, talk to witnesses, find out what's actually in that lake. If the sheriff's connected, the evidence will point us there."
"And if it doesn't?"
"Then we'll have a conversation about how reliable your 'instincts' really are."
The motel was typical Wisconsin tourism: lakefront views, pine-scented air fresheners, rooms that hadn't been updated since the Reagan administration. Ethan took the one next to the Winchesters, dropped his bag on the bed, and stared out the window at Lake Manitoc.
The water looked peaceful. Sunlight sparkled on gentle waves. Fishing boats dotted the surface, their occupants unaware of the deaths that had occurred in these same waters.
THEY DO NOT SEE. THEY DO NOT FEEL. THE DEAD WAIT BENEATH THE SURFACE.
"What's down there?"
RAGE. OLD RAGE. A CHILD WHO DROWNED AND A FATHER WHO WATCHED.
A child. Of course it was a child. The most terrible deaths always involved children—innocents whose lives ended before they had a chance to truly begin.
Ethan's sister had been innocent too. She'd trusted the wrong person, loved someone who didn't deserve it, and paid the ultimate price while her brother was deployed half a world away.
He couldn't save her. Maybe he could save whoever was about to die in this lake.
A knock at the door. Sam, alone, expression carefully neutral.
"Can we talk?"
Ethan stepped aside to let him in. "What happened at the sheriff's station—"
"I noticed." Sam sat on the room's single chair, folding his tall frame into the cheap furniture. "Your hands were smoking. Your eyes started to glow. Dean was focused on Devins, but I saw it."
"I had it under control."
"Did you? Because from where I was standing, it looked like you were about five seconds from attacking a law enforcement officer in his own station."
Ethan didn't deny it. "The Spirit reacts to guilt. Strong guilt triggers The Urge. Devins is carrying something heavy—something connected to deaths in that lake. My first instinct was to force him to confess."
"By doing what, exactly?"
"The Penance Stare. Make him experience his own sins reflected back at him." Ethan met Sam's eyes. "It wouldn't have killed him. Probably. But it would have broken him."
Sam absorbed this quietly. His expression was analytical, the researcher examining a new data point.
"You resisted."
"Barely."
"But you did. You walked away without hurting anyone."
"This time."
The admission hung in the air. Sam let it sit, not pushing, not judging.
"Dean thinks you might be dangerous," he said finally. "Not because of what you are, but because of what you might become. He's seen too many hunters go bad, let their instincts override their judgment."
"And you?"
"I think you're struggling with something you didn't ask for. I think you're trying to do the right thing in a situation that doesn't have easy answers." Sam paused. "I think I understand that better than Dean does."
Something shifted in Sam's expression—a shadow of recognition, of shared burden. Ethan remembered what the show had revealed about Sam Winchester: the demon blood, the psychic powers, the destiny that waited in his future like a coiled snake.
Sam carried darkness too. Different from Ethan's, but darkness nonetheless.
"We should focus on the case," Ethan said, breaking the moment before it became too intimate. "There's a vengeful spirit in that lake. We need to find out who it is and why it's killing."
Sam nodded, accepting the subject change. "I've started the research. The drowning pattern matches a case from thirty years ago—a kid named Peter Sweeney who drowned in 1970. His body was never recovered."
"And the recent victims?"
"All locals. All families that have lived here for generations. All with connections to the sheriff's department or local government."
"People who might have known Peter Sweeney."
"Or known what happened to him."
The pieces clicked into place. A child who drowned. A sheriff who carried guilt. Adults dying in the same waters where a boy lost his life thirty years ago.
This wasn't random. It was targeted.
"The ghost is killing people connected to Peter Sweeney's death," Ethan said. "People who knew what really happened. People who helped cover it up."
"That's my theory. But we need proof—physical evidence connecting Sweeney to the drownings, confirmation that the deaths aren't just accidents."
"There's a boy." The memory surfaced from Ethan's knowledge of the show. "Lucas Barr. His father drowned in the lake last year. He hasn't spoken since."
"How do you know about Lucas Barr?"
"I read the case files at the station." Not technically a lie—he'd scanned them while Dean was charming the deputy. "His mother is Andrea Barr, runs a local diner. The boy draws pictures constantly. Trauma response."
"You think the pictures might be connected?"
"I think a kid who watched his father die might have seen things that adults dismissed. Especially if the ghost is targeting specific families."
Sam was already reaching for his phone, pulling up local business listings. "Andrea's Diner. Open until nine. We should talk to them tonight."
"Dean should handle it. He's better with the soft approach."
"And you?"
Ethan turned back to the window. The lake rippled under evening light, peaceful and deadly in equal measure.
"I'll research Peter Sweeney. Find out what really happened in 1970. And try not to burn down the sheriff's station while I'm at it."
Sam almost smiled. "Progress."
"Something like that."
Andrea's Diner was crowded with the dinner rush when Dean and Sam arrived. Ethan stayed at the motel, buried in old newspaper archives accessed through the stolen phone and a library database that hadn't updated its security since 1998.
Peter Sweeney. Twelve years old. Drowned in Lake Manitoc on August 12, 1970. Body never recovered despite extensive searches. The official cause was listed as accidental drowning during unsupervised swimming.
But the details didn't add up.
Peter had been an excellent swimmer—his school records showed participation in junior lifeguard programs. The lake conditions that day were calm, no currents or undercurrents that should have posed a danger. And according to witness statements, Peter had been seen playing with two other boys near the water before he disappeared.
Two boys. Both from prominent local families. Both of whom grew up to become pillars of the Lake Manitoc community.
One of them was Sheriff Jake Devins.
Ethan's chest burned as he connected the pieces. The sheriff hadn't just known about Peter Sweeney's death—he'd been there. A twelve-year-old boy who watched his friend drown and then lied about it for thirty years.
The Urge surged, demanding action. Ethan forced it down, breathing slowly, methodically, refusing to let the Spirit's hunger override his judgment.
Evidence first. Justice could wait until he understood the full picture.
His phone buzzed—Dean's number.
"The boy's drawings are weird," Dean said without preamble. "Houses, bicycles, a church, something that looks like a kid underwater. Andrea says he hasn't spoken since his dad died, but he draws constantly."
"Does she know about Peter Sweeney?"
"She says no, but she got nervous when I asked about her father. Turns out Sheriff Devins is her dad. Lucas is his grandson."
Everything connected. The sheriff's guilt. The targeted killings. The boy who drew pictures of drowning children.
"Lucas saw something," Ethan said. "Something his grandfather's been hiding. That's why the ghost is targeting the family."
"You think the ghost killed Lucas's father?"
"I think the ghost is working through a list. Anyone connected to Peter Sweeney's death. Anyone who helped cover it up. The Barr family is connected through the sheriff."
Silence on the line. Dean processing implications.
"If you're right, Lucas is in danger. He's the sheriff's grandson—that makes him a target."
"Get back to the motel. We need to plan our next move."
"Already on our way."
The call ended. Ethan stared at his research, at the evidence pointing toward a thirty-year-old murder disguised as an accident, at a ghost that wouldn't rest until everyone involved paid the price.
His phone buzzed again. A text from an unknown number, containing only a photograph.
Lucas Barr's drawing. A red bicycle. An address. A lake.
And beneath it, in childish handwriting: He's still there. He wants to come home.
Lucas had found him somehow. Reached out through whatever psychic connection trauma and guilt had forged. The boy knew where Peter Sweeney's body lay—and he was begging someone to end the cycle.
Ethan grabbed his jacket and headed for the door. Time to find a ghost's grave.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1