Chapter 28: The Coffee Meeting - Part 1
January 10, 2009 - 1:45 PM - Surveillance Position
The coffee shop was called "The Daily Grind."
Corner location, large windows, multiple exits. Good visibility, public setting, escape routes available. I'd scouted it that morning, identified optimal parking spot half-block away with sight line to entrance.
Now I sat in my car, laptop open, receiver active, waiting.
Lorelei appeared at one-fifty, walking casually, no sign of nervousness visible. She entered the shop, and my earpiece crackled to life with ambient noise—coffee machines, conversation, background music.
The System tracked her vitals through the wire's feedback.
[ **MONITORING: LORELEI MARTINS** ]
[ **HEART RATE: ELEVATED (STRESS RESPONSE)** ]
[ **BREATHING: CONTROLLED** ]
[ **LOCATION: CONFIRMED** ]
[ **ENERGY: 59/100** ]
Two minutes later, I spotted Wagner entering. Mid-fifties, gray hair, leather briefcase, professional attire. He looked like every other consultant in Sacramento—respectable, trustworthy, completely ordinary.
"Predators look like everyone else. That's why they're successful."
"Dr. Wagner," Lorelei's voice came clear through the wire. "Thank you for meeting me."
"Of course. Please, sit." His voice was warm, paternal. "I'll order us coffee. What would you like?"
They ordered. Small talk about the weather, Safe Harbor's recent challenges, volunteer scheduling. Wagner was charming, relaxed, showing no stress markers.
[ **ANALYZING: DR. WAGNER (AUDIO PROFILE)** ]
[ **CONFIDENCE: 73% (AUDIO-ONLY LIMITATION)** ]
[ **VOCAL STRESS: MINIMAL** ]
[ **SUBJECT APPEARS GENUINELY RELAXED** ]
[ **WARNING: PRACTICED DECEPTION POSSIBLE** ]
[ **ENERGY: 57/100** ]
"I wanted to discuss your work at the shelter," Wagner said after coffees arrived. "You seem very invested in these women's welfare. More than a typical volunteer."
"I believe in the cause."
"Admirable. But I've noticed you asking questions about former residents. Their outcomes, where they went after leaving." A pause. "Is there a personal connection driving this interest?"
My hand moved to the car door handle. He was probing, testing, trying to determine Lorelei's real motivations.
"I just want to help," Lorelei said, maintaining cover.
"Of course." Wagner's tone shifted slightly—still friendly but more analytical. "You remind me of someone. A previous volunteer, actually. Young woman, very passionate about helping others. She asked similar questions about resident outcomes."
Silence. Then:
"Miranda Martins. Did you know her?"
The world stopped. Wagner had just named Miranda. Directly. He knew the connection—had known, probably since Lorelei started volunteering.
The System erupted with warnings.
[ **CRITICAL MOMENT DETECTED** ]
[ **SUBJECT WAGNER AWARE OF CONNECTION** ]
[ **THIS IS TEST OR THREAT** ]
[ **RECOMMEND: IMMEDIATE EXTRACTION** ]
[ **ENERGY: 55/100** ]
My hand was on the door, ready to burst in, when Lorelei spoke.
"Miranda was my sister."
"No. Don't admit it. Don't give him confirmation."
But it was too late. Wagner's voice came through the wire, and the tone had changed completely.
"I thought so. You have her eyes."
Not surprise. Sadness. Genuine, heavy sadness that the System flagged immediately.
[ **ANALYZING: EMOTIONAL AUTHENTICITY** ]
[ **GRIEF MARKERS: DETECTED** ]
[ **SUBJECT RESPONSE: GENUINE** ]
[ **LIE PROBABILITY: 11% - TRUTHFUL** ]
"I tried to help your sister," Wagner continued. "She came to me three weeks before she died. Said she'd noticed a man watching the shelter. Always in the parking lot across the street, different cars, but she recognized him. She was scared."
My entire theory collapsed in that single sentence.
"What did you do?" Lorelei asked, voice tight.
"I reported it to police. Filed an official statement, gave them her concerns, described the man based on her description." Wagner's voice carried frustration. "Two days after I filed that report, Miranda was murdered. And when I called to follow up, they told me the case was being handled, my statement was on file. I assumed they'd investigated."
[ **ANALYZING: WAGNER TESTIMONY** ]
[ **LIE PROBABILITY: 8% - HIGHLY TRUTHFUL** ]
[ **VOCAL STRESS ANALYSIS: GENUINE REMORSE DETECTED** ]
[ **SUBJECT BELIEVES HIS STATEMENTS COMPLETELY** ]
[ **PROFILE REASSESSMENT: NOT PREDATOR, POTENTIAL WITNESS** ]
[ **ENERGY: 52/100** ]
"He's not the killer. He's not Red John's associate. He tried to prevent Miranda's death and the police ignored him."
"The police report made no mention of your statement," Lorelei said.
"What?" Wagner sounded genuinely shocked. "That's impossible. I gave a detailed description, provided dates of sightings, everything. Detective... Hernandez, I think? He took my statement personally."
"There's no record of it. I've seen Miranda's entire case file."
Silence. Then: "Someone removed it. Or it was never entered properly." Wagner's voice hardened. "That man Miranda saw—he was watching the shelter for weeks. She noticed him, and three weeks later, she was dead. And my report disappeared."
The implications cascaded like dominoes. Wagner wasn't the threat. He was an overlooked witness whose testimony had been buried—either through incompetence or deliberate suppression. And the man watching Safe Harbor in 2003...
"That was Red John. Or someone connected to him. Wagner saw him, reported him, and nothing happened."
"Can you describe the man?" I asked through the wire, abandoning pretense of surveillance. "The one Miranda saw?"
Wagner's response came immediately. "Who is that?"
"My boyfriend," Lorelei said. "He's been helping investigate."
"I see." A pause. "The man was average height, maybe five-ten, brown hair, no distinguishing features. Generic looking—the kind of person you'd forget in a crowd. But Miranda said he had very intense eyes. Cold. Like he was studying the shelter, not just watching it."
The description was useless—too vague, too generic. Red John would be exactly that kind of forgettable.
"You said you gave this to Detective Hernandez?" I asked.
"Yes. Christopher Hernandez. Sacramento PD, assigned to Miranda's case. I met with him personally, gave him everything."
I pulled up my laptop, searching Sacramento PD records. Detective Christopher Hernandez, worked homicide 1999-2005, transferred to San Francisco after... the search froze.
Transferred after Internal Affairs investigation. Allegations of evidence tampering and taking bribes. Nothing proven, but enough questions that he left Sacramento.
"He buried Wagner's report. On purpose. Either he was dirty, or someone paid him to bury it."
The coffee shop meeting continued, Wagner and Lorelei exchanging information. But my mind raced ahead, assembling pieces:
Miranda noticed someone watching Safe Harbor. Wagner reported it to police. The report disappeared. Two days later, Miranda was murdered. Hernandez transferred out amid corruption allegations.
Red John or his network had infiltrated the investigation. Buried evidence, compromised the detective, ensured Miranda's case went cold.
And now we'd stumbled onto it, six years later, through a consultant everyone assumed was the predator.
The System provided final analysis.
[ **INVESTIGATION STATUS: PARADIGM SHIFT** ]
[ **DR. WAGNER: WITNESS, NOT THREAT** ]
[ **DETECTIVE HERNANDEZ: PERSON OF INTEREST** ]
[ **RED JOHN NETWORK: CONFIRMED INTERFERENCE IN 2003** ]
[ **DANGER LEVEL: UNCHANGED (DIFFERENT SOURCE)** ]
[ **ENERGY: 49/100** ]
Lorelei's voice came through the wire: "Thank you, Dr. Wagner. This helps more than you know."
"Find who killed your sister," he said quietly. "I couldn't save Miranda. Maybe I can still help bring her justice."
The meeting ended. Lorelei exited the coffee shop, walking toward my car. I started the engine as she climbed in, wire still active.
"You heard everything?" she asked.
"Everything."
"We had the wrong person."
"We had the right instincts, wrong target. Wagner's legitimate. But someone buried his testimony." I showed her the information on Hernandez. "This detective. He took Wagner's report and made it disappear."
Lorelei stared at the screen, processing. "So the killer—Red John or whoever it was—he had police connections. Enough to compromise an investigation."
"Or corrupt one detective. Either way, Wagner's testimony should have led to Miranda's killer. Instead it was buried, Hernandez transferred out, and the case went cold by design."
We sat in the car for several minutes, neither speaking. The investigation had just expanded from "find Red John's victim selection pattern" to "uncover police corruption from six years ago."
Bigger. More dangerous. And impossible to pursue through official channels.
"Where do we go from here?" Lorelei finally asked.
"We find Hernandez. Make him tell us why he buried the report. And we figure out who paid him to do it."
Her hand found mine. "This is bigger than we thought."
"I know."
"Are we still doing this?"
I looked at her—scared but determined, grieving but ready to fight. The woman I loved, asking if we'd continue hunting a killer who'd proven capable of compromising police investigations.
"Together," I said.
"Together."
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!