Walking away from the ice cream shop, Izuku idly slurped at the frozen chocolate drink through the plastic straw of his cup. It wasn't too often he indulged in sweets - usually when his mother was alongside him - but the cold was a nice contrast from the current season. Glancing at his companion, he watched as she sucked on her own strawberry confection by his side.
Seems she wanted to get ice cream, after all.
"You were right. This place is pretty good," he complimented her choice of venue. "Is the strawberry good?"
He hadn't been sure what to get, so he simply chose the chocolate milkshake after she'd picked the strawberry one. He would've picked that one too, but he thought getting the same option might be considered weird. He had no idea how to navigate himself in this fantastical scenario, doing his best to just roll with whatever came next.
His question caused her trademark smile to reappear in brilliant fashion. She held her cup out to him. "Wanna taste?"
A deep blush instantly appeared over his freckled cheeks. "N-no, that's quite alright. I-I couldn't."
"Come on! Do it, Izuku-kun!" She encouraged fervidly, pushing the straw to her drink closer to his face.
Right. She had begun using his first name, just like she did back then during their brief exchanges. That natural forward socialness hadn't changed.
"I-I really shouldn't," he shook his head rapidly, hiding his embarrassment by holding out his own towards her instead. "B-but you can try mine if you really want to. I-it's no trouble..."
He didn't need to convince her. Without looking, he could feel a light pressure on the top of his cup, and could hear small suckles come from his straw. He could feel his face burn even more, and couldn't dare to look back at her until she was finished.
"H-how was it...?" He asked awkwardly after feeling her pull away, daring to turn back and look at the bold girl.
She licked her lips, sending a shiver down his spine. "As good as always."
"...Good as always?" He repeated slowly. "You've had the chocolate kind before?"
"Of course!"
A sense of incredulity began to grow as she surprised him yet again. Was there a point to sharing if she had already known the flavor?
Did he just get played?
Her straw was once again shoved near his face. "Your turn!"
Feelings of shyness unfelt in years were being pulled by their threads as he warred with them internally. He could hardly remember the feeling before, and now that he was undergoing through these untapped emotions again, he decided he much rather preferred them to remain dormant. His eyes squeezed shut as he wrestled with embarrassment, and the urge to please her. He was a gentleman, but he had already broken that code to get this far.
He'd come all this way to forge a connection with her. A man's gotta do what a man's gotta do.
With trepidation, he inched forward and took one quick sip from her straw, feeling the creamy goodness of frosty strawberry enter his mouth before pulling away with lightning speed.
"You likey?" Toga asked, a hint of smugness in her tone. He could hear how pleased she was without even looking at her.
"...It's good," he forced out. The coolness of the drink didn't quell the warmth he felt, or his beating heart.
They continued their aimless trip down the city sidewalk, sipping on their drinks without much discussion. He appreciated the reprieve, lest his face burn off completely. He could use a lesson or two on how to be more suave.
Maybe his mom could let him practice?
...On second thought, maybe that was a bad idea.
"So, Izuku-kun," Toga spoke up, getting his attention. "Why did you go picking me out of the crowd? Did some of my friends come send you my way to cheer me up? Or maybe they wanted to mess with me?" She said that last part more to herself, glancing upwards in thought.
"No, there wasn't anyone who sent me over to you or anything. Although, I guess this is all pretty weird..." He muttered to himself. His plans to get here had been meticulous, but he couldn't figure out how to approach her for the life of him. Waiting for her by the front gate to call her out had been what he defaulted to. He figured as long as he didn't give up, he could acquire her attention.
She giggled at how straightforward he admitted it. "I don't think it's weird. I think it's fun!"
"You do?"
"Mm-hmm! We get to be together now. Isn't that great?"
"Yeah..." He replied slowly. It was a little unnerving how easily she was connecting with him. Maybe she was like this with everyone, or maybe he simply had good synergy with her. He was still grateful, at least.
"If you don't go to my school, then where do you go?" An honest curiosity shined inside her citrine gaze.
"Aldera Junior High."
Her head tilted cluelessly. "Hm? Where is that school?"
"It's over in Musutafu."
Her eyes widened in surprise. "You go all the way over there? Do you live there?"
"Yeah, I do."
"But that city is like, super far away. How did you get here?" Toga was starting to piece together the absurdity. He claimed he had come here for her, so it wasn't like he was on vacation around here. It just didn't make sense.
"I took a train. I had to get on it pretty early in the morning," Izuku told her honestly. He didn't have any intention to lie to her and saw no reason to. At least, nothing concerning this lifetime.
"You came all that way for me?" Her eyes shone, both in wonder and hesitation. There was clear doubt inside her orbs, but his story was just so fascinating, and he seemed so genuine that she wanted to indulge in the belief that it were true.
"Well, my school is actually competing in a debate tournament in this city tomorrow. I'm sure they'll be here sometime soon." He took a sip of his milkshake before continuing, "I guess you could technically say I'm here for that."
Toga hummed, as if she began to understand. Though his story had some holes, she believed she got the picture. "So you wanted to pick up girls in your free time, starting with me?"
He sputtered over his drink, coughing and clearing his air pathway. "N-no! Of course not! I wouldn't do something like that!"
"Hehehe~ you're so funny, Izuku-kun!" Toga laughed at his hysterical response. "Juuust kidding. I know you wouldn't want to pick up a girl like me." Her expression twitched, becoming something resembling rueful.
There was something sensitive inside her eyes, and a hint of forlorn sadness in her tone. His instincts compelled him to respond, but he hesitated. He didn't want to jump the gun just yet and set her off in a negative way.
This was all still so surreal. He was really walking and talking next to Himiko Toga. She only looked slightly different from the unsettling girl he knew from before - shorter and more underdeveloped. Her hair which had always been tied up into messy buns was also down, her dark blonde hair falling over her shoulders.
It was scary to think that this very person next to him would soon become a cold-blooded serial killer. She looked like such an innocent girl right now - she was an innocent girl right now. And deep inside that girl was a sleeping monster that could wake up any minute and reign terror on those around her.
But was she a monster?
Her actions painted her out to be. She killed others, sometimes brutally, all for her own self-fulfillment. She indulged in the usage of her Quirk, abusing it to no end by feasting on the blood of others without proper rhyme or reason. She hurt so many innocents, stole lives away from families, permanently destroying many households that could never get back what was lost. She did it without care or consideration, never thinking twice.
She did it all with a brilliant smile.
...But did that make her a monster?
Maybe it did... But that's exactly why he couldn't let her turn out that way.
The girl right next to him was not a monster. She was innocent. She hadn't done anything wrong. She didn't deserve to be ostracized or outcast.
He knew the report. He had read it thoroughly back in his prior life. Not all the details were known, but one day, she had simply snapped. She had injured and hurt a student whose name had been redacted, running away after she was caught. She never returned to school, or even home for that matter. That day, she had officially become a villainous vagabond.
What drove her to that?
He knew. He knew the moment he laid eyes on her.
She needed to be saved.
Saved... from herself.
