CHAPTER 43: THE FOURTH HUNT
POV: Alen
The hunt list contained seventeen names arranged by threat level and moral clarity, villains whose documented atrocities qualified them for soul harvesting without ethical complexity. But as Alen studied research materials spread across his dormitory desk, recognition crystallized that simple evil was becoming increasingly difficult to locate.
"Marcus Veld—unambiguous monster whose sadistic pleasure in torture made harvesting morally straightforward. Helena Voss—corporate torturer whose systematic cruelty justified execution. Greta Sienna—ancient vampire whose centuries of accumulated evil demanded cosmic justice."
"But the easy targets are gone. Remaining names carry moral complexity that makes cosmic responsibility feel like cosmic presumption. How do I determine who deserves death when motivations become mixed?"
Mara Blackwood occupied the fourth position—documented killer whose body count exceeded many war criminals but whose circumstances suggested motivations that transcended simple malice. Seventeen confirmed murders across decades of supernatural activity, each victim carefully selected according to criteria that remained frustratingly unclear.
"Dark witch operating in shadows, systematically eliminating targets through magical assassination that leaves no conventional evidence. Pattern suggests organized campaign rather than random violence, purpose beyond simple homicidal impulse."
Lily entered his room with research materials that provided context his enhanced abilities couldn't access alone, hybrid perspective offering insights into supernatural communities that operated beyond normal magical classification.
"Mara Blackwood," she announced, settling beside desk with expression mixing admiration and concern. "Also known as the Shadow's Scalpel, the Coven's Executioner, the Righteous Reaper. Seventeen kills confirmed, dozens more suspected."
"Tell me she's unambiguously evil," Alen said with voice carrying desperate hope for simple moral clarity.
"She's a guardian," Lily replied, destroying comfortable assumptions with clinical precision. "Every victim was threat to hidden supernatural community—peaceful coven of witches who've maintained secrecy through careful population control."
"Guardian. Protector-executioner who kills to prevent massacres, individual violence that serves collective survival. Seventeen murders to save hundreds of innocent lives—does mathematical utility justify cosmic intervention?"
Enhanced research revealed pattern that made moral assessment increasingly complex—each victim had been investigating supernatural activity, preparing exposé that would reveal coven location, organizing hunting expeditions that threatened community extinction. Mara's systematic elimination had prevented genocide through preemptive assassination.
"She's choosing who lives and dies," Hope observed, having joined research session with expression mixing understanding and uncomfortable recognition. "Like you."
"Parallel that cuts deeper than casual observation. We both execute threats to people we love, both justify killing through protection of innocent lives, both carry burden of deciding who deserves death for greater good."
"Seventeen murders," Alen said, voice carrying weight of cosmic responsibility that demanded objectivity despite emotional complexity.
"To save hundreds," Lily countered with logic that made ethical assessment feel inadequate. "Does mathematical utility matter when calculating moral justification?"
"Utilitarian mathematics versus absolute moral authority. Do numbers justify execution, or does individual life possess value that transcends collective benefit? How do I weigh seventeen deaths against hundreds of lives saved?"
POV: Alen
The coven's hidden sanctuary existed beneath modern Portland, underground complex carved from living rock while magical wards hummed with protective energy that spoke of centuries of careful concealment. Alen's enhanced senses catalogued defensive systems that rivaled Salvatore School's security despite serving community of peaceful practitioners.
Mara Blackwood waited in central chamber with expression mixing expectation and resignation, dark witch whose appearance defied stereotypical assumptions. Middle-aged woman whose gentle features carried weight of accumulated moral compromise, protector whose hands bore blood of necessary violence.
"The coin maker," she said without preamble, voice carrying recognition that transcended normal supernatural awareness. "Come to harvest me for resurrection currency? How wonderfully recursive—killer hunting killer for cosmic justice."
"She knows about harvest methodology. Understands soul extraction process that was supposed to remain absolutely secret. Corporate surveillance has expanded beyond Triad into supernatural communities I thought were isolated."
"You've killed seventeen people," Alen announced with voice carrying authority that cosmic responsibility demanded despite growing uncertainty about moral justification.
"To protect," Mara replied with calm certainty that made accusations feel inadequate. "Like you will, eventually, when numbers get too large for individual salvation. When choices become impossible and mathematics replace morality. Don't pretend we're different."
"We're not different. Both executioners who justify killing through protection, both weapons pointed at threats to people we love, both carrying burden of deciding life and death for cosmic purpose beyond individual comprehension."
She attacked without warning—dark magic erupting like controlled explosion while reality bent around spells that exceeded normal witch capabilities. Shadows became solid weapons, gravity reversed selectively, space folded to make distance meaningless.
Alen siphoned her assault while enhanced abilities flowed through combat that felt more like philosophical argument than physical confrontation. Each spell carried weight of moral justification, each counter-attack suggested alternative approach to cosmic responsibility.
"She fights to escape rather than kill, violence measured to prevent pursuit without causing unnecessary harm. Even in combat, she maintains principles that make execution feel like cosmic overreach."
Hope and Lily arrived with vampire speed and tribrid fury, flanking attack that forced Mara toward defensive posture while enhanced coordination overwhelmed individual resistance. Dark witch collapsed beneath combined assault, magical reserves depleted through systematic drainage.
"Who decides who's villain enough to die?" Mara asked from magical containment that sparkled with binding energy. "You? Corporate executives with surveillance equipment? Ancient entities playing cosmic chess with mortal lives? Kill me, and you're proving we're identical."
POV: Alen
Decision point crystallized around moral complexity that made cosmic responsibility feel like cosmic arrogance, enhanced abilities demanding ethical assessment that transcended simple utilitarian mathematics. Mara Blackwood represented first target whose motivations suggested heroism rather than simple evil.
"Seventeen murders to prevent community genocide. Systematic assassination of threats who would have killed hundreds through exposure and hunting expeditions. Individual violence serving collective protection through preemptive elimination."
"But who grants authority to decide life and death? Divine mandate, cosmic responsibility, mathematical utility, or simple power to enforce personal judgment? What makes my moral assessment superior to hers?"
Hope studied his expression with understanding that transcended normal supernatural perception, tribrid nature detecting internal conflict that enhanced concealment couldn't hide completely. "She's not purely evil."
"But she's dangerous," Lily added with hybrid perspective that provided tactical rather than ethical assessment. "Systematic killer whose methodology could be applied to innocent targets if circumstances changed."
"Dangerous but not evil. Methodical but not malicious. Protective but not purely heroic. Gray morality that makes cosmic judgment feel like personal presumption rather than divine authority."
"Every resurrection coin has been purchased with unambiguous evil—Marcus Veld's sadistic pleasure, Helena's corporate torture, Greta's ancient cruelty. Clear moral distinctions that made harvesting feel like cosmic justice rather than personal execution."
"But Mara represents first target whose motivations mirror my own, whose methods parallel cosmic responsibility, whose violence serves protection rather than simple destruction. Harvesting her would mean acknowledging that I'm villain in someone else's story."
"Entity granted wishes without moral framework, cosmic power without ethical instruction manual. Maybe cosmic responsibility means choosing mercy when mathematics suggest execution, maintaining humanity when utility demands compromise."
"I can't kill her," Alen decided, voice carrying weight of cosmic choice that felt more significant than simple mercy. "She's gray, not black. Morally complex rather than purely evil."
Mara's expression shifted toward surprise that transcended simple relief, recognition that cosmic judgment had included compassion rather than pure utilitarian assessment. "You're more ethical than I expected. That humanity will break you eventually."
"Maybe," Alen agreed, releasing magical containment while enhanced abilities stepped back from execution that felt like cosmic overreach. "But I'd rather break than become monster who kills for mathematical convenience."
"Releasing documented killer whose methods parallel my own, whose protection might include future violence against innocent targets. Choosing mercy that might enable tragedy through moral complexity that defies simple assessment."
"Find non-lethal methods or I come back," he warned with authority that carried cosmic weight despite ethical restraint. "Protection doesn't require murder if creativity provides alternatives."
Mara nodded with understanding that suggested respect for moral limitation, professional acknowledgment between killers who chose different approaches to cosmic responsibility. "I'll adapt. But remember—when your own numbers become too large, when mathematics overwhelm morality, you'll understand why I chose simplicity over complexity."
POV: Alen
Return journey passed in contemplative silence while enhanced consciousness processed implications of decision that felt simultaneously heroic and strategically foolish. First harvest attempt that ended in mercy rather than coin collection, moral complexity overriding cosmic utility despite potential consequences.
"Three resurrection coins remaining from previous harvests. Stefan already restored, two more opportunities to rewrite tragedy through villainous sacrifice. But fourth coin requires target whose evil justifies execution without moral compromise."
"Easy villains are gone, leaving targets whose motivations include protection alongside violence, whose methods serve noble purposes through terrible means. Cosmic responsibility becomes personal judgment when moral authority lacks divine mandate."
Hope maintained supportive silence while tribrid perception detected internal conflict that enhanced abilities couldn't fully process. "You made the right choice."
"Did I?" Alen asked with voice carrying weight of cosmic uncertainty. "Seventeen murders might become twenty, thirty, fifty if circumstances change. Mathematical progression that makes mercy feel like delayed execution."
"Or seventeen murders might become zero if alternative methods prove effective," Lily countered with hybrid logic that provided optimistic interpretation. "Moral choice that prevents future violence through ethical constraint rather than preemptive elimination."
"Unknown outcome wrapped in hopeful assumption. Mara's adaptation could include pacifist methodology or escalated violence depending on community threats that haven't yet materialized. Mercy as cosmic gamble rather than certain virtue."
That evening brought research into remaining hunt targets, seventeen names arranged by documented atrocities but complicated by motivations that defied simple moral classification. Corporate executives whose supernatural experiments served national security, cult leaders whose apocalyptic visions included genuine prophetic elements, vampire lords whose territory control prevented chaos through authoritarian stability.
"Gray morality everywhere, simple evil increasingly rare in supernatural community that operates according to survival principles rather than malicious pleasure. How do I harvest sufficient coins when ethical restraint makes targets inappropriate for execution?"
"Entity's cosmic chess game demands resurrection currency while moral development prevents easy acquisition. Cosmic responsibility evolving beyond utilitarian mathematics toward ethical framework that might compromise cosmic purpose."
"Four more coins needed for mysterious cosmic purpose that remains hidden. But first coin requires target whose evil justifies harvest without moral compromise—increasingly rare qualification in supernatural world where protection and violence intertwine."
The hunt would continue, but parameters had shifted toward ethical complexity that made cosmic responsibility feel like personal judgment rather than divine mandate. Mercy had been chosen over utility, humanity over mathematics.
Whether choice proved wisdom or folly would depend on future consequences that enhanced awareness couldn't predict despite cosmic knowledge that remained frustratingly incomplete.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
Can't wait for the next chapter of [The Originals/Legacies Im A Saltzman]?
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them (20+ chapters ahead!). No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1