Chapter Fifty-Two – So Much to Take In
Warmth spread through him as he delved deeper into Jack's lovely ass. From behind, Vince pressed against him, and he was doing so much more than that. Theodore wouldn't have thought in his life that he would ever enjoy someone doing such a thing to him. In the world of humans, he had been an inveterate top, which meant that he had never experienced having a man possess him.
Vince's cock was filling him up slowly. The guardian was obviously a considerate lover. Theodore could tell it was true by simply observing the way Vince slowly caressed his shoulders only to squeeze them firmly when he needed to push inside some more.
It took Theodore a good moment to realize that the soft sound he heard, at the same time low and manly, belonged to him. He was the one expressing his pleasure in the most sensual of ways, by groaning and moaning and asking for more without forming the words needed for it to become reality.
At the same time, despite his earlier fears, Jack was taking him quite well. For a guy as skinny as he was, Jack definitely had a nice behind. Theodore let his hands run over Jack's back, resting his fingers on his hips and then pulling him hard toward him.
"Wow," Jack moaned, "I think I can feel the head of your dick in the back of my throat."
Theodore chuckled. "I know I'm big, Jack, but the only way for me to penetrate your tight throat with my cock is by letting you give me head."
The lewd words slid off his tongue naturally. During all his encounters from before, when he'd spent time with his so-called human lovers, he had been nothing but restrained. He didn't waste words on his bed partners. Usually. Now he was mating with these two gorgeous people, and he wanted to use all the words he knew to express all the pleasure and all the need he had for his mates.
Vince was, without a doubt, experienced. His rough hands moved over Theodore's chest, his fingers quick to pull at his nipples and torture them.
He rewarded his guardian mate by throwing his head back and moaning loudly.
"Ah, I'm sure you two are having so much fun doing whatever it is that you're doing back there, and I can't see," Jack expressed his frustration.
Normally, a chatty lover would annoy the living daylights out of him, but this was Jack, and everything the clairvoyant said so easily turned into sex talk.
"Are you a voyeur, Jack? Would you like to watch me and Vince mate?"
A shiver coursed through Jack, making Theodore aware that he, too, could use words to arouse his mate.
"I'd love that." That was Jack at his most honest, and Theodore could tell it was so. Jack continued. "You are both so buff. I bet you look so good together. Vince tapping your ass, you taking it--"
"What if I want to mount Vince, too?" Theodore asked.
His breath was coming fast now. Vince, the skilled lover that he was, changed rhythm and angle slightly with so much finesse that Theodore felt like a musical instrument in the hands of an experienced musician.
It didn't cancel what he was doing to Jack. No, this double-fucking was working like a charm for him, and if there was any doubt that Vince and the clairvoyant both were his mates, this would be the moment to establish that Jack's cards didn't lie.
The more Vince penetrated him from behind, the more need Theodore felt to impale his smaller mate with his cock. His manhood was so stiff he could split logs with it if he put his mind to it. But he didn't want to break logs. He only wanted to break Jack in the most beautiful of ways.
"Can you feel me, Jack?" He, the silent lover, was hungry for validation.
"O-ho," came the immediate agreement. "You have no idea. My ass is getting bigger and bigger. I wonder if it might turn into a black hole and swallow everything."
"You'll swallow everything, I'm sure," Theodore said, his voice coming out in staccato bursts. "Vince," he whispered, "slow down a bit. I think I'm losing my mind if you continue to do me like this."
"And? How is that a problem?" Vince asked.
"I want to have Jack come first," he explained. "What kind of alpha am I if I neglect my mate's needs in favor of getting off myself?"
"With us," Vince said tenderly, "you don't have to worry about such things. We are here to serve you, alpha. Both of us."
There was just something in the way Vince was saying that, in how he was calling him alpha that made Theodore come undone.
"Jack," he warned, "I'm afraid you'll have to take a serious pounding on account of me being subjected to Vince's dirty talk."
"Dirty talk? I haven't even started," Vince teased him, biting his ear and pinching one of his nipples only, most likely, to hear him cry out.
Despite all the physical turmoil he was in, of the most pleasurable kind, Theodore felt an inner peace inside him. He was safe. He was back with his pack. And he had his mates. His two wonderful mates who were ready to do anything for him, just as he was ready to do for them.
"Ready for your first alpha load?" he grunted, infected by his mates' ability to talk sexily and dirty, the good kind.
"I got one in my belly not that long ago," Jack said, but it was easy to tell that his voice was strained because he, too, was getting closer and closer to his climax.
"This one will go inside your ass. You'll be full of me. You will be my mate." Theodore felt sweat pouring down his back as he increased his effort to pound Jack's lovely ass.
"I am already your mate," Jack confessed. "Your mate that's shooting hands-free right now."
Jack was right about the need to see more. He, too, would have loved to watch Jack come, but given their sex position, what they could witness visually was limited.
Later. He'd make sure that his mates would serve him and he would serve them in all possible positions. He would satiate his hunger by watching them writhe under him, surrender to one another—
Now that was quite the picture his mind was painting. He could so easily imagine Jack's slender frame in Vince's strong hands, the way the guardian's large dark cock would disappear in the clairvoyant's insatiable pink hole.
"This is it," he whispered, a quiet shout of victory for himself, as his climax soared.
Jack's moans mingled with his. He heard his smaller mate giving a running commentary while shooting wildly, while Theodore did the same.
And that wasn't all. Vince wasted no more time. Confident that his mate would be able to take it, he was hammering Theodore's ass fast. This was a mating he'd remember each time he'd try to sit for a while. But it was a small sacrifice seeing what he was getting in return.
"Good job, alpha," Vince praised him as if he knew exactly what he needed to say to make Theodore lean back against him and abandon himself to his wet kisses, as well as to Vince's hard coming inside him.
He had a feeling he might begin to enjoy being praised for his great deeds.
***
Vince held Theodore in his arms, knowing that the alpha – his alpha, their alpha – needed the support. The muscles on Theodore's lower abdomen tensed under his fingers as he caressed his lover. It was easy to tell what was happening south of the border, because Jack's play-by-play was loud enough to make everyone in a fifteen-mile radius privy to their mating ritual.
"How is it, Theodore?" he asked in a gentle voice. He had one hand wrapped around the alpha's throat to enjoy feeling his pulse quicken. "I'm marking you, deep inside your body. You are so deliciously tight, do you know that?"
Theodore's incoherent moans as he continued to shoot his cum inside his other mate were the only confirmation he needed for his actions.
His alpha enjoyed being owned. Finally, he was embracing the fact that he was mated to a loyal guardian and a cute clairvoyant.
"Are you happy?" Vince ran his lips across Theodore's collarbone, the side of his neck, his ear, everywhere he could reach.
"Happy doesn't begin to cover it, Vince," Theodore replied eventually, his breath still fast and hitching.
"Good. I am proud to say that I didn't lose my touch. I made you come so hard."
Teasing was in the cards when three guys like them reached their final agreement.
"You and Jack, both," Theodore said. The last shivers of his climax shook his body briefly.
"Yeah, don't forget about me," Jack quipped. "Vee, I got so fucked by Theodore."
Vince laughed. "I think I heard you clearly enough. Are you still convinced that Theo ripped you a new one?"
"You should check."
Theodore moved slightly away and let his huge alpha cock slid from Jack's well-used ass. That was quite the sight, and Vince was the first to admit it. Theodore's cum was pouring out, but Jack's ass pulled tight, so the clairvoyant really had nothing to worry about.
"Don't mind me if I do." Vince moved his hand lazily to grab Jack's ass playfully. His own cock remained lodged inside Theodore, and it looked like his faithful little – or not-so-little – fellow didn't want to get out of that warm hole anytime soon.
Vince pushed in a few more times, although he was spent for now. Seeing how sexy his two mates were, he doubted that he would need too much rest between mating sessions. The only question that remained was simple: who would do who? He didn't dare to ask it just yet, since their alpha might want to dictate the terms of their mating, at least for the time being, while they were still inside this special magical cave.
***
Mating was definitely interesting. To think that he had worried about the size of Theodore's dick so damn much. Jack felt quite proud of himself. After all, how many people could say that they were capable of taking such a huge thing and the load that came with it?
Not many. Jack didn't need to run surveys to have the answer to his question. But there was one person he did want to see taking it from Theodore and that was Vince.
Both his mates were now playing with his ass. His very full of alpha jizz ass. Although he understood the appeal. A need to finger himself rushed over him even as Vince's rough fingers probed him and Theodore squeezed his ass.
"I'm not a butt virgin anymore," he blurted out, though he had no idea why.
It had been so pleasant to feel Theodore pushing inside him and conquering all his fears, although he had no intention to admit to having experienced the latter. Ever.
He rolled on his back and lifted his legs high. "Since you two are so interested in seeing my ass and how huge it got because of Theo's big dick, here's another angle to view it from."
Theodore and Vince knelt in front of him and got dangerously close. Their dicks were half-limp now, and that was like saying that Jack was trying to see the full half of the glass, because damn, the look in his mates' eyes was one not so easy to ignore.
"Why are you both looking at me like that?"
"How are we looking at you?" Theodore cocked his head to one side, with a pervy smile on his face.
Vee, unfortunately, didn't look like he had purer thoughts on his mind. Suddenly, Jack didn't think that his decision to fully display his ass like that had been a smart idea. He made a move to drop his legs and strategize his retreat, but there was no hope left for him.
Theodore caught him before he could get away. Jack covered his face. "Stop staring at my leaking hole like this. I'm going to combust."
"You don't have to feel ashamed at all, Wolfie," Theodore teased him.
"Ah, and you're calling me by my nickname. How am I supposed to resist you?"
"You are not supposed to resist me. You are my mate."
"Good answer. I mean, as good as any," Jack hurried to say.
Theodore was now holding his ankles together with one hand and slowly moving his fingers over Jack's puffy asshole and his ball sac. It was really pleasant, and Jack reckoned that he might enjoy lying like this for a while.
"Am I allowed to join in on the fun?" Vince asked.
Theodore made room for him, and now they were both fingering Jack slowly.
"Not that I'm complaining, but what are you two doing?"
"Getting you ready, of course." Vince and Theodore looked at each other as if they were only then reaching an understanding.
"You two are complotting, I'm sure."
"Can you guess about what?" Vince teased him with a grin.
"It involves my asshole," Jack said gamely.
"Yes. Since you're a seer, I'm sure you only need to put your mind to it, and you'll learn right away what your immediate future holds."
Jack had an inkling but he didn't dare to speak out loud. It was like something taken out of a very kinky fantasy. He was getting red in the face only thinking it.
"Come on," Theodore teased him some more, grabbing his ball sac and playing with it.
Jack could tell his little friend was looking forward to whatever it was. "Stop it, you don't even know if we can handle it," he reproached right away.
"We can handle it," Vince hurried to assure him.
"I wasn't talking to the two of you. I was talking to my dick. And my asshole, which is a bit of an afterthought if you're asking me."
Theo and Vee laughed together, both at the same time, making Jack blush.
"Come on," he complained, "I can so tell that you are thinking of some dirty, but really dirty things."
"We are, actually," Theo decided to tease him a little more. He pushed another finger inside Jack's ass, making him squirm in pleasure. It looked like not only was he getting the hang of this buttfucking thing, but he was also willing and eager to get more of it.
Vince had two fingers inside him, too, and he was busy exchanging glances with Theodore. From time to time, they kissed and smiled at each other.
And their cocks were getting harder and harder. Jack had a difficult time trying to keep track of everything because there was so much to take in. Literally.
First of all, his mates were freaking beautiful together. Vince had always been a swell guy, and Jack knew he could depend on him and his honest smile. Theodore, on the other hand, always brooding, always angry, looked so different, yet so the same. His face was relaxed, his smile was bigger than the sun, and Jack could read that tender look in his eyes as if it was something out of a fairytale.
An X-rated fairytale.
"Are you going to double-tap me?" he blurted out. Yes, his mind was going there. Yes, he even hoped for it.
Clearly, he was turning into a slut for alpha dick and guardian dick. His menu was varied.
"If by that you mean that we will double-penetrate you," Vince said, a naughty dimple quickly appearing on his cheek, "yes, Jack, that's exactly what we're thinking."
"Two cocks? In my ass?" Jack shouted.
"Don't you feel up to it?"
That was Theo asking, always ready to be kind.
Jack wanted a little less kindness, and a little bit more dick. Wow, now he had truly become a mate for an alpha and a guardian. He was ready to take it.
"I'm so ready," he replied.
He still protested at being manhandled and hiked up in their arms, though his mates were careful not to stretch him too much between them. That was more for show, because he needed to run his mouth so he didn't have to think that, soon, he'd have not one, but two giant cocks inside his tiny asshole.
Surely, his tiny asshole would have to learn that not all fantasies were doable. Still, when Vee and Theo kissed him on his cheeks, sandwiching him between them, Jack knew he'd found his courage and would never let go of it.
He had no idea who went in first, but his ass was happy to receive the intrusion. When the second cock joined, that was when things got real.
"Oh, fuck," he exclaimed.
The same sense of wonder was shared by his lovers.
"Wow, Jack," Vee whispered, "you're really tight."
"I know. How come you're both inside me?"
"We insisted," Theo joked. "This is so good, Jack. You're good."
Jack squirmed as the pressure inside his ass mounted. His mates were barely moving, holding him up in the air, and fucking him slowly. Still, tears erupted from his eyes, caused by too much stimulation.
"So good," he whispered, throwing his head back.
And his dick twitched because it wasn't every day that he mated with an alpha, gained another mate in a strong guardian like Vee, lost his virginity, and went down the kinky path so hard that he was now getting double-penetrated.
What a day. A full day, if he could say that, while losing his mind from too much pleasure.
Vee and Theo were whispering and moaning in his ears, making him dizzy in the best way possible. Their cocks were rubbing against each other inside Jack's ass, which meant that they were fucking each other, too, somehow. Jack's sex vocabulary needed more words to describe what was going on.
For now, he'd settle for being grateful about receiving a double load inside his ass while his dick pulsed and shot like the little pervert it was.
TBC