Back in the quiet, respectable boarding house, the war room came alive.
Gone was the air of a merchant's holiday. The suite had transformed into a conspiratorial cell. On the table lay a map of Vienna, a list of names, and a stack of socialist pamphlets — their new weapons of war.
Koba stood at the head of the table, voice low and commanding.
"A direct approach is impossible," he said. "Trotsky is surrounded by acolytes. To approach him as an unknown would invite suspicion."
His eyes flicked to Ivan. "Violence is off the table. In this city, a quiet man with a secret is more dangerous than a loud man with a bomb. We will not be loud."
He tapped a name on the list — Adolf Joffe. "We don't need Trotsky. We need the man who opens the door to him."
Joffe was young, brilliant, and devoted — Trotsky's right hand. Koba had watched him at the Café Central, saw how he anticipated his leader's moods, how he guided the group's debates with subtle authority. He was the gatekeeper.
"How do we get to him?" Murat asked. "Bribe him? Threaten him?"
Koba shook his head. "The currency here isn't money or fear. It's ideas. A new idea is worth a fortune — and deadlier than a gun."
He gestured to the thick sheaf of handwritten pages beside him — the thesis he had once presented to Lenin. "Trotsky's gospel is 'Permanent Revolution.' Romantic. Optimistic. He believes war will ignite a spontaneous uprising of workers across Europe. My thesis," Koba said, tapping the papers, "is its opposite. Cold. Brutal. A vision of a war that crushes the proletariat before it frees them. That's what will draw them in."
It was an intellectual trap — a honeyed lure made of logic and fear.
Murat was chosen as the bait.
Quick-witted, charming, and less intimidating than the others, he could blend in easily. His cover changed from "Herr Müller, the timber merchant's assistant" to "Mikhail, a disillusioned student from Graz." A quiet young intellectual fascinated — and troubled — by a dark new theory about the coming war.
For three days, Murat lived the role.
Koba drilled him not on lies, but on arguments. He had him memorize every point: German industry, Russian logistics, the Schlieffen Plan, the inevitability of trench warfare. Murat learned to speak like a man haunted by the future.
Then he went into the field.
He haunted the same cafés, the same reading rooms, the same smoky backrooms where Joffe and his circle debated socialism over black coffee. For days, he was a shadow — listening, watching, blending in.
Until his chance came.
A small reading group was arguing over a new article by Karl Kautsky. Joffe was there, dismantling the others with effortless precision.
That's when Murat spoke.
He didn't attack Trotsky. He praised him. "Comrade Bronstein's analysis of the revolutionary potential of the Russian proletariat is brilliant," he began, voice steady and earnest. "But… I fear we are debating the politics of a world that's about to end."
The room went still.
Then he began to lay out Koba's theory — not as a provocation, but as a confession. The coming war would not spark revolution, he said. It would annihilate it. The masses would march under flags of patriotism, not socialism. Industry would devour men faster than bullets.
He spoke like a believer losing faith.
The other students shifted uncomfortably. But Joffe leaned forward, fascinated. Here was something new — something that smelled of heresy and truth at once.
Afterward, he approached Murat. "Your analysis was… unorthodox," he said, eyes bright. "But compelling. I've never heard such a grim, realistic argument. You must tell me more."
Over the next few days, Murat and Joffe met again — "by chance."
Each time, Murat gave a little more, revealing fragments of Koba's theory, always positioning himself as a humble student struggling to understand. Joffe, flattered and intrigued, began to draw him out — to think he was the teacher guiding a gifted pupil.
Until, finally, Joffe asked the question Koba had built the entire operation around.
"This theory of yours, Mikhail," he said one afternoon over coffee, "it's brilliant. Did you create it yourself?"
Murat smiled, modest but nervous. "No, Comrade Joffe. I'm just a student. The ideas belong to my mentor — Herr Schmidt, a scholar in Graz. A recluse, but a genius. He sees the war not as an event, but as an inevitable collapse of civilization itself."
Joffe's eyes lit up. A hidden mind, a forgotten theorist? He had to meet him.
"I must speak to this man," Joffe said eagerly. "Lev Davidovich must hear him."
And just like that, the trap was set.
The meeting was arranged for Thursday at three in the Volksgarten. A public park, open and safe — or so it seemed.
Koba would play the role of Herr Schmidt, the quiet scholar from Graz. Murat would watch from a distance, hidden among the trees.
When the day came, the air was crisp, the sky clear. Murat arrived early and took up his position. He scanned the path — and froze.
Joffe was coming through the gate. But he wasn't alone.
Beside him walked a familiar figure, animated and intense, gesturing with one hand as he spoke. The pince-nez glinted in the sunlight. The wild hair caught the breeze.
Trotsky.
Murat's stomach dropped.
The plan had changed. Trotsky hadn't sent his lieutenant — he had come himself.
Murat watched as the two men strode down the gravel path toward a solitary figure sitting on a park bench, calmly reading a newspaper.
Koba didn't flinch.
He folded the paper and looked up.
Joffe smiled in greeting. Trotsky's eyes, bright with curiosity and confidence, met his.
The debate Koba had planned for one student had just become something far greater — a collision of two future titans.
The war of ideas had begun.