Andrew was lost between watching Jessica bouncing on Austin and the sight of the two beauties next to him, both engaged in their own passionate exchange.
On one side, there was his sister, the object of his affection and desire, being pleasured by another man. And on the other, there were two beautiful women kissing and touching each other while one of them took his cock deep into her.
The contrast, the chaos—it was dizzying. He couldn't figure out what to feel at that moment.
His instincts as a lover and a man were at war with his possessive nature. He wanted to be everything for Jessica, yet here he was, unable to stop her from experiencing someone else, nor could he ignore how much she was enjoying the company of another.
"Austin... you're so deep... harder... fuck me harder..."
Jessica's voice that seemed to carry across the room didn't help him either. Every word, every moan, seemed to drive him further into his inner conflict.
"Ahhh... Mphh... Andrew, I'm loving it... Mhmm... deeper..."
Then there was Katrina, her pussy tightening around him as he drove into her again and again, her walls massaging his length from all sides, which brought pleasure to his lower body while still messing with his head.
It all became too much to handle, so Andrew took out his frustrations on Katrina's body with his vigorous thrusts. He grabbed a handful of her orange hair and yanked it back, forcing her to arch her back and expose her neck, then leaned down to bite it.
"Ahhh! Shit! Yes! That's it, rough me up, Andrew!" Katrina hissed in a mix of pain and delight, then craned her neck even further, giving him more access to mark her as he pleased.
And that's what Andrew did—he nipped, licked, and sucked on her soft flesh with an animalistic hunger that made Eva pause her kiss and watch, mesmerized.
Andrew let loose on Katrina, each thrust more powerful than the last, each slap of flesh against flesh louder than the previous.
It was like he was trying to drown out the image of Jessica and Austin with the force of his actions, trying to prove something to himself, or perhaps to her.
"Ahhh... Andrew, I can't... hold it anymore... Mhmmm," Katrina moaned as she felt an orgasm approaching.
"Hold it, Katie. Don't you dare come yet," Andrew commanded, still not letting up on the intensity of his pounding into her from behind.
He was being unreasonable, he knew, but he didn't care. This was his release.
However, Katrina couldn't hold on for long. A few more deep thrusts from Andrew, and she screamed as her orgasm washed over her, her pussy walls clamping down hard on his cock like a vice.
"AHHHHNNN! I'M CUMMING! AHHHHH!"
And that triggered her release. Andrew could feel the hot wetness flooding around his cock, lubricating it even more as her juices mixed with his pre-cum.
Seeing Katrina lost in her own pleasure, Andrew couldn't maintain his rhythm, for he wanted to let her enjoy her orgasm.
After all, the pleasure should be enjoyed by two people instead of just one.
So, he stopped and pulled his thick meat out of her dripping pussy. Which had stopped her from spilling her juice all over the bed.
When Andrew looked at Eva, he found her with a look of longing in her eyes but also a hint of fear.
"No. Andrew. I can't. My pussy feels sore, and I don't want to feel pain. I've had enough fun for one night," Eva shook her head, her eyes full of pleading. "If you want more, I can use my mouth or hands, but not my pussy. Please."
Andrew had to admit that the fear in her eyes made him want her more. But he also wasn't the type to force someone.
"Andrew, if you can hold for few minutes more, then I will be more than ready to take your hot rod deep inside me again," Katrina chimed in before Andrew could say anything to Eva.
However, Jessica's loud moaning interrupted them. "Ahhh... Andrew, if you want to join me, I will surely welcome you in my backdoor. You know I would love to have both of you at once, filling me from both sides."
Those words seemed to flip a switch in Andrew's mind, and his frustration turned back to anger.
'This bitch of a sister is asking for it now. She knows I don't like the idea of sharing her, and yet she's pushing my buttons.' Andrew thought, narrowing his eyes at Jessica before shifting his gaze to Austin. 'Fuck it, I need to drain this anger before I do something stupid.'
"You want to have my cock in your ass, huh? Fine. I'll give it to you," Andrew said in a low, dangerous tone that made everyone shiver.
"Hahaha! Of course, Andrew. I can take you anytime and anywhere," Jessica replied without a trace of fear.
Instead of arguing with her, Andrew moved from Katrina and Eva and towards his sister. Then, grabbing Jessica by the hips, he positioned his body behind her.
At the same time, he gestured towards Austin. "Keep her tight, man. And don't you dare pull out."
Austin's mind was already overloaded when Jessica made the suggestion, and now with this added command from Andrew, he couldn't help but follow along. He held Jessica's back tighter, his movements stilling for a moment to let Andrew make his move.
It was like he should follow every word of Andrew if he didn't want himself to be in trouble.
"You're such a greedy girl, aren't you, Jess?" Andrew whispered while moving his hand to her buttocks. Then he spanked her ass cheeks hard, earning a yelp of surprise from her. "Wanting to take two men at once. What a slut."
"Mhmm... yesss... I'm your slut... now hurry up and put it in..." Jessica gasped, wiggling her ass to tease him.
[ Hungry for more? Check my Profile Bio and find my Personal Page through Discord. Character Arts are also Available there. ]