"Of course, Your Highness," I said. "I'm curious what you want to discuss."
That much was true. The rest, I kept to myself.
The problem with Cecilia was that she was the princess of the Empire I lived in. My family's home was in its capital. Openly crossing her would be political suicide, for me and possibly for them.
But that didn't mean I had to dance to whatever tune she played.
The waltz carried on, the orchestra playing with the polished, soulless care expected at Academy functions. Cecilia dropped the teasing and settled into the rhythm without any more tests, as though she'd already got the answer she wanted.
When the last notes faded, we parted with the customary nod, the one that meant nothing at all in the language of the nobility.
She moved to take my arm. I offered it before she could.
"The balcony has a good view," I said. "And fewer people."
Her eyes flickered. She'd been planning to steer me there herself.
A dozen pairs of eyes followed us across the ballroom. I could almost hear the Academy's private ledger being rewritten as we passed: the commoner, the Saintess's date, now walking out with the Slatemark princess.
In the novel, the extra called Arthur Nightingale had spent this night somewhere at the back of the hall, if he'd been there at all. Now I'd waltzed with the Saintess, danced with the Slatemark princess, and was walking her out onto a moonlit balcony in front of half our year.
So much for staying out of the story.
Outside, the air was cool and clean. It carried the scent of night-blooming flowers from the gardens below, and the faint tang of ozone that always hung around a crowd of powerful mages. The sky was deep indigo and crowded with stars, sharper and brighter than any I'd seen in my old life. Below us, the Academy grounds rolled away into darkness, the trees of the forest moving gently under a full moon.
Cecilia leaned against the stone railing, the moonlight catching in her golden hair. It made her look more beautiful, and somehow more dangerous.
I stood a comfortable distance away. Close enough for conversation. Not close enough for anything else.
"Lovely night," I said. Then I looked at her. "But I doubt you brought me out here for the weather."
She smiled. With Cecilia, a smile was never just a smile. It was amusement, curiosity, and something slightly predatory, like a cat deciding whether the mouse was worth the effort.
"You want to ask me something, right?" She tapped one nail against the stone. "So ask."
She was handing me the first move. Fine.
"I've noticed some tension between you and Rose Springshaper," I said. "You're both talented mages from strong families. I'm curious about the history."
The question hung between us.
Cecilia's smile widened a little. Not enough to be reassuring. Just enough to be unsettling.
"Oh, Rose Springshaper?" she hummed, as though she'd been reminded of a mildly interesting memory. Somehow the way she said it made the name smaller. "Like me, she was a disciple of the Tower of Magic when we were younger. Before either of us came to Mythos."
She traced an idle pattern on the stone with one finger.
"The Tower of Magic," I said. "That explains her skill. It must have been competitive."
"Of course." Her tone was light, almost sweet. "But I'm a Slatemark. My talent is far above hers, especially with my Mind aspect Gift. The instructors saw it immediately."
She said it the way someone might say the sky was blue. Not an insult. A fact.
"The little girl could never keep up. However hard she tried. However many hours she spent in the practice chambers, however many books she memorised." Something darker crossed her eyes. Not quite satisfaction, but close. "It must have been… difficult for her."
Something in the way she said it made my stomach twist.
I thought of Rose in the café that week, gripping her skirt while Morris's friends laughed. Of the way she went quiet whenever Cecilia entered a room, like someone listening for a step on the stairs. Whatever had happened in that tower, Rose hadn't walked away from it thinking it was a matter of talent.
I didn't know the truth. I only knew that this wasn't all of it.
"Competition drives people to extremes," I said. "But in my experience, the most stubborn people have a habit of surprising everyone."
Her eyes sharpened at that.
"Trust me, I never hurt her," she said, waving a hand as if brushing away an accusation I hadn't made. "She hurt herself. She pushed too hard. Reached for things she couldn't hold." Her smile turned thoughtful. "Ambition without limits is its own kind of poison, don't you think?"
"Perhaps," I said. "Or it's how impossible things get done. It depends where it's pointed."
I held her gaze. "Thank you for telling me. It helps."
She studied me for a long moment. In the moonlight, her crimson eyes looked almost black.
"You're very diplomatic, Arthur."
"I try to be fair. Everyone has their own side of a story."
"Mm." She turned so her back was to the railing, elbows resting on the stone. "My turn, then. Why do you care?"
"About Rose?"
"About Rose." Her smile curved. "I hear she's your only friend. Some boys in a café were saying so."
So that had already gone round the Academy. Of course it had.
"Then I'd better look after the one I've got," I said.
Cecilia looked at me for a long moment, and something moved behind her eyes that I couldn't read. Then it was gone, tucked away wherever she kept the things she meant to think about later.
Before she could answer, a new voice cut across the balcony.
"Cecilia. Arthur."
Rachel stood in the doorway, the light from the ballroom behind her, her sapphire eyes fixed on Cecilia.
"Rachel," I said. "Good timing. We were just talking about the Tower of Magic."
Cecilia, predictably, looked thrilled. The slight widening of her smile suggested she'd been hoping for exactly this.
"Are you jealous, Rachel?" she asked, all mock sympathy. "Did you think I was stealing your precious Arthur away for something wicked?" She laid a hand over her heart.
"Princess Cecilia was telling me about her training," I said before Rachel could answer. "It sounds like an intense place."
Rachel's eyebrows rose slightly. Cecilia's smile dipped by a fraction.
"Don't worry, Ray-Ray," Cecilia added sweetly. "I'll give him back. Eventually."
A muscle jumped in Rachel's jaw.
"Of course not," Rachel said, taking my lead. "I'm just surprised you'd choose somewhere this public for a history lesson."
"I should head back in before people start talking," I said, and turned to Cecilia with a polite nod. "Thank you for the conversation, Your Highness."
Cecilia blinked. She clearly hadn't expected me to be the one to end it.
"Naturally," she said slowly. "We should continue this sometime. I find your… perspective… very interesting."
"I'd be honoured," I said, and went inside.
"Why are you doing this, Cecilia?"
Rachel's voice was calm. Too calm. She stood with her arms crossed, watching the other girl closely.
They had known each other almost their whole lives. Summit dinners, coronation anniversaries, state visits where the children of the Seven were seated together and told to be friendly. They had hated each other since they were small enough to need cushions on their chairs. Rachel couldn't remember a single one of those dinners that hadn't ended with one of them in tears, and she was honest enough to admit it hadn't always been Cecilia who'd made someone cry. Inside, the music had changed to something slower and sadder, which felt about right.
Cecilia tilted her head, the very picture of innocent curiosity, though nothing about her had ever been innocent.
"Doing what?" she asked, twirling a strand of golden hair around one finger.
"Playing with Arthur." Rachel's eyes narrowed. "He's a fast learner, sure. But is he really that interesting compared to your usual… entertainment?"
Cecilia shrugged, an elegant, practised movement.
"Not really." She examined her nails. "He's just another Academy student. Talented. Unusual, maybe. But hardly unique."
Rachel's scowl deepened. On her, it looked out of place. "Then what are you doing?"
Cecilia leaned back against the railing.
"Instincts."
Rachel didn't move. But something in her posture tightened, the small, involuntary adjustment of someone who understood exactly what that word meant.
Coming from anyone else, it would have been a throwaway excuse. Coming from Cecilia Slatemark, it meant something else entirely.
Because Cecilia, like Rachel, was special. Not in the born-with-talent way that filled Mythos Academy. Not even in the prodigy-of-a-generation way that described Jin or Ren.
Cecilia was a witch. More than that, she had the potential to become an archwitch: a being so rare and so singular that the world itself seemed to bend around it.
Witches weren't evil. They were simply different, as rare and unnatural as draconic humans, touched by a power that ignored the usual rules of mana.
And Cecilia was still awakening. Just as Rachel was.
Which meant there were things inside her that even she didn't understand yet. Wants that came from somewhere beneath thought. Instincts that whispered up from the depths of a power still opening its eyes.
Rachel knew what that felt like. She wasn't sure she'd ever forgive Cecilia for making her feel they had that in common.
"Anyway," Cecilia said lightly, stretching her arms above her head, "he's useful to me. For now."
Rachel's jaw tightened. "Useful?"
"Mhm." Cecilia turned a lazy smile on her. "Just a tool. Nothing else. Something to keep me entertained until something better comes along."
Rachel took a step towards her.
"You don't keep tools, Cecilia. You keep toys. And you break them when you get bored." Her voice stayed quiet. "Don't break this one."
For a heartbeat, Cecilia actually looked surprised.
Then the smile came back, slower and sharper than before, like a predator that had just been shown where the soft spot was.
"Why not?" she said silkily. "It's the same for you, isn't it?"
Rachel's lips parted.
"You told me yourself the other day," Cecilia went on, her voice sweet with false concern. "You're using him. So you don't have to go with Lucifer." She leaned on the name, just slightly, knowing exactly what it would do.
Rachel went completely still.
Lucifer Windward. Everyone's answer. The boy their fathers talked about over dinner as if the matter were already settled. The boy who was polite to her, always, the way he was polite to everyone he'd decided was useful, and who looked at the heirs of the Seven the way a player looks at pieces on a board: each one in its place, each one there to be moved.
She hadn't wanted to spend tonight as one of his pieces. That was all.
That was all it was supposed to be.
Cecilia watched her through half-lowered lashes, the satisfaction of a nerve struck plain in the curve of her mouth. Then, with a mocking little hum, she turned and strolled back inside, her gown shimmering in the moonlight.
Rachel stood alone, her fingers gripping the stone railing until her knuckles whitened.
'That girl is dangerous.'
More than most people realised. More, perhaps, than Cecilia herself understood.
"Seraphina."
Rachel turned. The half-elf had stepped onto the balcony without a sound, her silver hair catching the moonlight. Rachel hadn't heard the doors. She never did, with Seraphina. Even now, she hadn't worked out whether that was a technique or simply who Seraphina was.
Seraphina greeted her with a single nod. Nothing more.
'Princess of Mount Hua.'
A girl as quiet and detached as Jin. She drifted through conversations rather than taking part in them. Unlike Cecilia, all sharp words and tangled amusement, or Ian, with his easy warmth, Seraphina seemed to live in a quiet world of her own, her ice-blue eyes taking in everything and giving nothing back.
Rachel sighed, suddenly exhausted.
'Why is Class A so difficult?'
She turned to leave.
"I never thought the Saintess would stoop to using someone."
Rachel froze mid-step.
Seraphina hadn't moved. Her arms were folded neatly in front of her, her expression unreadable. No judgement in it. No sympathy, either. Just observation.
"It's more complicated than that," Rachel said. It sounded hollow even to her.
She thought of the limousine. Her hand on the clasp of her bag. Seraphina's eyes moving, once, from her knuckles to Lucifer and back.
Seraphina had seen. Seraphina saw everything. She simply didn't usually bother to say so.
"If you say so." Seraphina's voice was calm and indifferent. And yet. "But in the end, you're just running away, aren't you?"
Rachel's fingers curled at her sides, her nails pressing into her palms.
Seraphina held her gaze a moment longer. Then, as though the conversation had already stopped mattering, she turned and went back inside, as silently as she'd come.
Rachel stood there for a long time, the night wind cold against her bare shoulders, staring at a sky full of stars that didn't care either way.
She thought of the classroom after World History, the day she'd asked him. Of asking him, in front of everyone, and of the way he'd gone quiet before he answered. Not shy. Not flattered. He had looked at her as if he were weighing something far heavier than a dance, something she couldn't see.
And then he'd said yes anyway.
She'd been so pleased with herself. A clean escape. A kind boy who wouldn't make demands. She hadn't once stopped to ask what it might cost him.
She had no answer.
Or she had one, and didn't have the courage to look at it. Which felt worse, somehow, for a girl the whole world already called the Saintess.
When she finally went back in, Arthur was standing just inside the balcony doors.
He had two glasses in his hands. He held one out to her without a word.
Rachel took it. For a moment, she just looked at him.
She was good at reading people. She always had been. It was how she'd survived a lifetime of ballrooms, how she knew which smiles were real and which were knives. So she read him now, the way she'd read everyone she'd ever met.
He wasn't angry. He wasn't hurt. He wasn't even curious. There was no question waiting behind his eyes, no hint that he wanted her to explain herself.
He knew.
She didn't know how, or since when. Maybe Cecilia had told him on the dance floor. Maybe he'd worked it out in Maven, in that mirrored salon, when she'd talked about the way Lucifer danced. Either way, he knew, and he'd said yes anyway, and he was standing here holding a drink for her.
"Arthur," she said. "Why did you say yes?"
He considered the question as if it deserved a proper answer.
"Because you didn't want to go with him," he said. "And I didn't mind."
Rachel opened her mouth. Nothing came out.
It would have been easier if he'd been angry. Anger she knew how to deal with; she had been dealing with it her whole life. She could have apologised, or argued, or smiled until it went away.
But he wasn't asking her for anything. He'd simply decided she was allowed to have her reasons, and that was the end of it.
Nobody had ever done that for her before. Not without wanting something back.
"It's fine, Rach." He offered her his arm. "Come on. You still owe me another dance. I've only practised the one, so you'll have to lead."
Despite everything, she laughed.
"You were fine in the first one."
"I stepped on you twice in Maven."
"Three times." She sniffed. "I counted."
"Then you'll definitely have to lead."
She slipped her hand through his arm and let him walk her back towards the light.
'Running away,' Seraphina had said.
Maybe she was.
But for the first time that night, Rachel wasn't sure what she was running towards.
