Just then there was another clicking sound as the door opened, and a silhouette stepped inside.
Both of them froze, and it was Jack who quickly reached for the blanket to hide their naked bodies as someone slowly approached the bed where they lay together.
Then they felt that person climbing onto the bed and moving towards sleeping Amara.
'Oh no... It seems Luke is planning to sneak under her blanket and fuck her in her sleep. Should I stop him? If I do it, it will blow our cover and give us away for sure... Gahhhh! What do I do?' Jack thought to himself in panic as he felt like the situation had spiraled out of control.
Brianna noticed Jack's sudden nervousness and quickly kissed him to stop him from thinking about unnecessary things.
This calmed him down, and he embraced her back, returning her kisses passionately.
Meanwhile, Luke managed to sneak under the blanket and began to caress Amara's thick thighs. They felt silky smooth under his fingertips but, at the same time, very firm because of the firm muscles underneath.
And with her sleeping on her stomach, he had easy access to her round ass that he couldn't help but grope, kneading and massaging it with his hands.
'I've wanted to play with this ass for a while now. It's a shame that Jack always keeps an eye on you. But tonight I'll finally have some fun...' Luke whispered before smacking her butt cheeks and parting them open with his palms.
Then he brought his head closer to Amara's slit and began lapping at it gently with his tongue.
Although her moans were muffled by the pillow she slept on, Luke felt excited every time she moved and writhed under him. Soon the juices started to drip from her wet pussy.
'Ahhh... Right there... Please go deeper...'
The sweet sound of Amara's voice and the lewd movements of her body filled him with lust, and he quickly devoured her pussy like it was his last meal.
Hearing the muffled moans of his girlfriend made Jack feel uncomfortable.
It was evident that his best friend was pleasuring his beloved partner with his tongue.
And the thought of someone else enjoying her body like this made him both jealous and angry.
Still, he couldn't complain or say anything to stop him because his cock was throbbing inside of Brianna's cunt. 'This feels so wrong. I should not enjoy fucking my best friend's girl. I should not let him lick my girlfriend either... And yet I'm doing nothing to stop any of it.'
With Luke's tongue, lips, and teeth attacking her cunt mercilessly, Amara couldn't help but moan louder. 'Mhmmm... Fuck! Luke! You really couldn't stop yourself, could you? Hehe...'
That was the cue for him to stop and move away from under the blanket as the room was filled with sudden silence.
'You were awake all this time?! Are you fucking kidding me?! You got me scared here...' Luke exclaimed angrily while wiping off her pussy juices from his face. He knew that if Amara didn't want to let him touch her body, then he wouldn't have gotten close to her pussy in the first place.
However, she giggled and lifted her head from the pillow to look at him. 'Instead of asking me about that, aren't you worried about Brianna? She's sleeping right next to me. I wonder, how are you going to explain this to her?'
'What is there to explain? I snuck into her room to fuck her. And by mistake, I thought you were her. That's what we have to say to her. The only thing that matters is whether you're ok with it or not.' Luke responded honestly with his typical shameless tone.
Amara shook her head with a chuckle before glancing towards Jack and Brianna. "I don't know if your explanation would go so smoothly. Since Brianna heard everything you just said, right?" She asked, turning on the bedside lamp and bringing the dim light into the room.
Both Jack and Luke flinched when they heard her. They didn't expect the other girl to know about their actions.
"You bitch! Why would you expose me like that?! We could have continued pretending to be unaware of each other's deeds. Wouldn't it be more exciting to continue our secret affairs?" Brianna pouted while looking at her best friend, who continued to grin.
"Aww! Come on, Brianna. Since the boys are the ones who came here to fuck us, why should we hide anything? Instead, it's more fun to bring it out into the open and spice things up even more." Amara suggested and gave her friend an eager wink.
Then she looked at her boyfriend, Jack, who was still buried inside of Brianna's pussy. "And I'm guessing you're enjoying Brianna's tight cunt, my love? Why don't you go ahead and continue to fuck her while your best friend plays with me?"
"What... Jack! You bastard!" Luke jumped back with wide eyes, a shocked look on his face at the discovery. But then he groaned in pain as Amara slapped him across the face.
"Shut up and listen for a moment. You were licking my cunt with all of your might only a minute ago; don't complain now." Amara chided and slapped him again on the other cheek to make sure he focused on her. "Anyway, don't act innocent just because you weren't the first one to cheat. Besides, Jack mistook her for me, unlike you, who knowingly wanted to fuck me. So don't start any unnecessary drama when everyone is enjoying themselves. Don't tell me that you suddenly changed your mind and don't want to continue where you left off."
Hearing her explanation, Luke's expression became less serious.
"Well, when you put it like that, I guess I should keep going instead of being upset." Luke smiled at her, still feeling a little surprised about getting slapped by a woman. "And you really have quite a wild side. I have never met a girl who would be ok with their boyfriend fucking someone else, not to mention actually encourage it."
Amara grinned back at him and then gave Jack a mischievous smirk. "Oh! You have no idea. Besides, it will be like a win-win situation. I get to enjoy a good fuck from you while Jack is having a piece of Brianna. So it won't be too bad, right, Jack?"
The only reply Amara got was a long, drawn-out sigh. It sounded like Jack finally relaxed after learning that there wouldn't be any problems between the group because of their cheating.
"I swear, this is getting crazy. First I cheat on you. And then you encourage me to continue while simultaneously cheating on me with my best friend." Jack shook his head in disbelief, but a smirk appeared on his face as he accepted that things had gone a little too far.
"Come on, Jack! You make it sound like you aren't enjoying fucking me when I know your cock is still pulsing inside my tight pussy." Brianna said with a giggle before moaning out. She closed her eyes and began bouncing her hips as the throbbing cock inside of her moved again.
Read more chapters here: https://subscribestar.adult/midnight_tales